4 ms·
I'm surprised that Fred didn't identify this as a cyclical phenomenon in computing. The history of computing is the cycle between centralization of compute (Ma
by AndrewKemendo 8y ago
I'm surprised that Fred didn't identify this as a cyclical phenomenon in computing.
The history of computing is the cycle between centralization of compute (Mainframe, Cloud) and decentralization (Desktop, Edge) from the users perspective. It's been going on forever and I don't see it stopping because of the computing cost cycles and increasing network speeds.
We're going to push more compute to mobile devices, then back to mesh networks etc...
- olivermarks 8y agoFred is applying this tech logic specifically to Crypto's evolution.
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoI think the cycle still holds even with Crypto. If you look at the primary platform where velocity is happening in the crypto space (number of transactions or touch points) - coinbase - it's a centralized broker for crypto. Individuals aren't mining their own coins, they are buying them from more and more centralized miners.
- olivermarks 8y agoI'm intrigued because historically currencies tend to get 'rolled up' - euro centralization of european currencies around the (very secretive) ECB is a good example. I agree with your point about the tech world centralizing and decentralizing in sequence (thin clients/cloud etc) but in the monetary world there seems to be far more momentum to centralize than decentralize. We even see this in banking - there are 5 big high street banks in the uk and 100s of local banks in Germany, who arguably are the defacto central bank of the european union. Closer to the center equals more options for diversification. This may be a similar scenario with crypto, especially now security tokens are increasingly asset backed.
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoDifferent time horizons, but it actually happens there too, only it looks like the disintegration of nation states into smaller states and then centralization again. Interestingly there haven't been as many of these monetary cycles in history since the emergence of major centralized banks, which is a good thing. So there is a (strong) argument that currency centralization is a driving force in stability and peace.
- adrianratnapala 8y agoThe correlation is clear, and probably meaningful. The causal are are complicated. Countries that have been at peace a long time, and which have whatever institutions and habits encourage such peace are also ones that can grow big multi-national corporations including banks.
- chuhnk 8y agoCompletely agree with you. Its very interesting, for those of us looking at computing trends we see it, and the token economics just play a role in this as the foundation for m2m payments going beyond api tokens. What I'm interested to see if decentralised networks built on top of AWS and others. Leveraging what's there, which is what we do when building any next step in the cyclical trend, always reusing past layers.
- devman0 8y agoI've noticed other cycles in my career as well such as cycling between preemptive and cooperative multitasking over about 10 year periods.
- im3w1l 8y agoIt has flipped back and forth but that doesn't make it a cycle. Cycle implies that it keeps oscillating on its on. But to me it seems more likely the flipping has been driven by outside forces. That one approach was genuinely better for a time and then in a subsequent period the opposite was genuinely better.