4 ms·
There is nothing that prevents AWS from using it's own systems as business intelligence for creating their own competitive products. Think about it like "store
by AndrewKemendo 8y ago
There is nothing that prevents AWS from using it's own systems as business intelligence for creating their own competitive products.
Think about it like "store brand" software. If people seem to be installing docker on 40% of AWS instances, then evolving Amazon ECS to include an Amazon branded Docker clone, effectively replacing Docker, is a no-brainer.
Seems like this is the way they are going. No need to acquire companies if you can just build infrastructure or services natively that work more easily.
Terrifying times out there for starting a software company.
- beginningguava 8y agoIt should fix itself eventually, either companies will choose to use Google or Microsoft rather than AWS or the government will smack AWS with monopoly laws. The main concern there is that Bezos has become so entrenched in DC with the washington post, DOD cloud contract, and new headquarters that it's hard to tell if we can rely on the government to do anything
- zapita 8y agoWhat makes you think Azure and Google aren’t doing the same thing?
- matte_black 8y agoAmazon is entrenched in a lot more than just government. Consumers, shareholders, merchants... a lot of people depend on Amazon to be around and in good health.
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoHonestly I doubt it. 1. If Amazon is providing a service that is as good or easier to implement than others, people don't care enough about competition or open markets to decide based on that. 2. From the govt perspective, I'm on the front lines of the DoD cloud discussions and I can tell you that even though we don't want a single provider, and hopefully I can push hard to ensure we have multiple providers, Amazon has the mindshare in the govt and growing.
- talawahdotnet 8y agoThey don't really need to do anything sneaky to figure out what to build next. They generally build things that their customers are banging down their doors asking them to build. The main difference with AWS vs Azure or Google is that they have been focused on the space longer and they have really optimized the rate at which they can build out a new scalable, reliable, secure, mananged service. Sure, the UI/UX is usually not great, and the documentation is imperfect and there are features missing, but they get the hard things right, they charge per second/hour/GB, and they improve over time.
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoAgreed. They just do a really good job of providing services and support. That's the point though. If people are happy with them, then there's no need for consumers to change and they won't change just because "we don't want to work with Amazon." Arguably though the US Government (as a customer) has a role to actively encourage a competitive market.
- xchaotic 8y agoGiven that there's special clouds just for gov agencies and now even an HQ near DC, somehow I can't see gov being able to oppose Amazon lobbying
- smt88 8y ago> Sure, the UI/UX is usually not great, and the documentation is imperfect and there are features missing, but they get the hard things right, they charge per second/hour/GB, and they improve over time. This is why I recently switched to Azure. UI is a million times better, and each product seems to work. Documentation is fantastic. AWS is full of bugs and stagnant products that overlap. It’s an absolute mess.
- cle 8y agoHave you thought about why?
- mbesto 8y ago> Terrifying times out there for starting a software company. - High free cash flow businesses that other traditional industries salivate over - Unlimited rapid scalability - Virtually no up front computing costs and virtually elastically tied to usage growth - Limited vendor lock-in Yes, truly terrifying. /s
- AndrewKemendo 8y ago- No personnel, pay/benefits, recruiting or technological advantage over FAANG - No speed to scale advantages over FAANG - No rapid scalability outside of a FAANG owned platform - No advantage in new/exiting/upcoming technologies or verticals that FAANG doesn't already have projects in All the advantages you identify also reside natively inside FAANG, while they have no barriers to scale, with a larger sales force and more easily integrated platform.
- mbesto 8y agoYour overall premise of "There is nothing that prevents AWS from using it's own systems as business intelligence for creating their own competitive products." is spot on. But characterizing the situation as "terrifying" seems just a little bit disingenuous. It's a double edged sword. All of the factors you mentioned are characteristics of any fortune 500 business. Are you familiar with the Innovator's dilemma? > - No personnel, pay/benefits, recruiting or technological advantage over FAANG Says who? Don't people leave FAANG companies all of the time because they realize they have technological advantages or don't have the right people? Good example - Otto. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Otto_(company) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Otto_(company) > - No speed to scale advantages over FAANG So let's ignore the agility and nimbleness associated with startups then? Isn't that precisely why so many software startups have been created in the last 15 years? > - No rapid scalability outside of a FAANG owned platform Microsoft would like to have a word with you. Ok snarky I know...I get your point. But, the rapid adoption of cloud is creating more and more cloud providers. Since lock-in is less of a problem which means we're getting more vendors with equally competing offers (just look at Equinix, Flexential, Digital Ocean, Linode, Pivotal, Rackspace, etc...just to name a few). Why do you think Azure/AWS/GCP all keep lowering their prices? > - No advantage in new/exiting/upcoming technologies or verticals that FAANG doesn't already have projects in What does this even mean? If a FAANG company doesn't have a project in the new/exciting/upcoming technology but you do and you prove the commercial value, then you absolutely have an advantage, no? You're there first! If, as you point out in your original post, FAANG sees that your offering has commercial value (they see more people adopting your technology) then they have to catch up to you anyway. You have a new competitor now, sure, but that is going to happen regardless of whether AWS exists or not. Is it a problem because they have the intelligence to approach the market quicker...sure. Not to mention, your ability to scale was already provided by them! Ultimately, you're complaining that the company that helped provide the scale is now competing against you? Boohoo. If this becomes such a huge problem than another provider will come along and create a "we won't compete against you" policy and change the market. I just don't see why that's such a problem. > All the advantages you identify also reside natively inside FAANG I think you've just proven my point. There is a level playing field when it comes to the technology services available to startups. FAANG's have a capital advantage and startups have an agility advantage. There's obviously a lot more nuance to that, but this isn't a terrifying situation at all.
- erikig 8y agoAnd not just software either. I strongly believe that this monitor-and-replicate methodology is part of why Amazon Prime Video has legs. Any content provider that uses AWS is just helping to train the beast. That beast might not seem like a threat but it will begin to rival and eventually supplant and usurp its antecedent.
- shostack 8y agoI've often wondered this about any tech company that provides infrastructure, analytics, or marketing/advertising tech. If they get customers who compete with another of their businesses, what exists to protect customers physically, technically, or legally? Seems like a great way to get paid for competitors to do market validation and then swoop in and clean up.