4 ms·
The intent of the plugin should not be illegal - that is what this battle is ultimately about, and this takedown action is essentially baseless bullying via the
by mindslight 8y ago
The intent of the plugin should not be illegal - that is what this battle is ultimately about, and this takedown action is essentially baseless bullying via the legal system. Each party to a transaction has their own desires, and what these companies are ultimately trying to do make you conform to their internal business desires post facto.
In any transaction there is a demarcation point where interests meet and then part. Businesses have gotten used to this idea of decommodifying [0] their products rather than competing - spamming restrictive clickwrap "licenses" etc. So much so that we view common sense rights like "first sale doctrine" as a friendly exception rather than the bedrock norm. A website telling you how you must/mustn't display the page you've retrieved is equivalent to a retail store demanding a share of your business's profits if you use their products commercially. We can envision such a scheme being cooked up with "terms of sale" and blah blah, but people would rightfully not stand for it - markets and society simply cannot function with such top-down control.
The only difference here is that civilization needs to re-figure these things out for the digital world, especially as frivolous overenforcement appears to be much easier.
[0] Adding unnecessary complexity/restrictions to make their market less efficient. See also: net neutrality.
- lazulicurio 8y agoYou know, I consider myself fairly liberal on technical issues, and I agree with you in the general sense, but I don't agree in this specific instance. This isn't a situation like Aaron Swartz, where the companies in question are restricting access to publicly-funded research. The newspapers are privately-funded entities that conduct their own investigative journalism. This isn't a situation like Weev, where there was no access control to the data and he was just probing exposed endpoints. This isn't a "right of first sale" issue. It could be if the publishers were trying to restrict access to page content after you paid for an account, but that's not what's happening here. I agree with the GP that the issue is the framing. It's the difference between selling a mask, and selling a mask that's advertised to let you rob a bank without being caught.
- mindslight 8y agoMy argument isn't based on liberating content, but that it's simply not one's responsibility to implement someone else's business rules. The problem is that the publishers are still supplying their content for free, while then trying to attach arbitrary post-facto terms. It would be straightforward to just not send the article to someone they don't want to view it, but yet this is not what they have chosen to do.
- lazulicurio 8y agoThe terms aren't post-facto, they're a priori. You can access the content if you paid for an account or if you're Googlebot. Impersonating Googlebot doesn't change the terms of the access. Note the description from the add-on page "This extension will mangle your browser's requests to maximize the chances of bypassing paywalls". This is where there's a meaningful difference from the Weev situation. You can also choose to not read the content if you don't feel it's worth the money.
- mindslight 8y agoThe protocol is the transaction demarcation point - anything else is sophistry. Let's try out an analogous argument with physical goods: Customer goes to Home Depot, buys a bunch of $5 aviators. Sells them on Amazon for $50. The distributor sues the customer-reseller for violating their contract to not commercially resell, which undermines their expensive offerings. Customer points out they never entered into any such contract at Home Depot. The distributor claims Home Depot is a mechanical conduit that only facilitates a larger relationship, and the transaction actually took place between the customer and distributor, with the "standard" terms having been available on request. The fundamental truth is that the interests of any buyer and seller are only aligned at the exact time of sale - afterwards they diverge. What has happened is that pervasive information technology has got sellers attempting to retain some kind of interest in things after they've sold them, with the "transaction" never really ending (an oxymoron). Copyright is one of the hooks by which they're purporting to do this (which actually at the very least it needs to be reformed so a seller of "digital goods" cannot destroy your access to a copy you've paid for) As I said before, society cannot function this way - non-pure ownership can work for big tickets (eg real estate), but centralization and every item having a history simply doesn't scale. And as I also said, there is a very simple remedy for publishers - stop sending the article to people they do not want to view it! (Your argument also implies that it is illegal to suggest someone visit a URL with lynx to avoid a javascript popup)
- schlumpf 8y agoYour retail store analogy is a red herring. A browser plugin that “maximizes the chances of bypassing paywalls” is attempting not to be party to a transaction, because if it succeeds, the user has expressly not agreed to the seller’s terms. Instead your position appears analogous to arguing that altering a driver’s license to gain free admission to a cinema by misrepresenting oneself as entitled to senior citizen terms of entry is justifiable despite being prohibited by law in that jurisdiction. It’s clear from this and other posts that you have articulate, principled view on many issues. So why aren’t you addressing the underlying economic issue? Publishers, like any business, need to earn revenue. If technological barriers to accessing intellectual property — and the legal protection thereof — are not valid (your claim of “frivolous overenforcement”), whose economic rights supersede the content producers? And why?
- mindslight 8y ago> whose economic rights supersede the content producers? The owner of the computer they're insisting implements their business logic. It's trivial to simply not send the article to someone they do not want to view it. If the extension moves on towards sharing an account, P2P distribution, etc, you would have a point. But as it is, it's only action is to interpret the content in a different way than the publisher desires. Let's say an abutter of a drive-in theater sets up their own seats and starts selling tickets. The intent to "see a movie for cheap" would only become relevant if coupled with some action that is actually illegal.