3 ms·
Well, the stiffling of funding to symbolic AI is a real danger. The field just keeps shrinking. And it's not just funding. Many people entering machine learning
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
Well, the stiffling of funding to symbolic AI is a real danger. The field just keeps shrinking. And it's not just funding. Many people entering machine learning today would simply not know a predicate if it leaped up and bit them in the existential quantifiers. They also have no idea that the field they are now joining en masse actually started out with learning in the propositional calculus, neither do they understand why it then moved to statistics.
In short, there is a real risk that researech funding will go to support research that doesn't know its elbow from its knee, done by people who don't understand what they are doing (because they don't understand what was done in the past). That is not a rosy situation.
I get the counter point- I'm myself a bit annoyed by Marcus' insistence on how deep learning is not true AI. Very few people really expect to see "true AI" in our lifetimes. A classifier that works well is probably the best we can do and it's very reasonable that there is such excitement about the fact that we can do it. But if we spend too much effort developing classifiers, well, we'll have great classifiers. And nothing else.
And then- what?