3 ms·
>granted land as a reward for their brutality in combat. Isn't that also revisionism? You don't exactly win wars by being chivalrous. Hacking some one to death
by benj111 8y ago
>granted land as a reward for their brutality in combat.
Isn't that also revisionism? You don't exactly win wars by being chivalrous. Hacking some one to death at point blank range isn't ever going to be nice.
We attach similar ideas today, to modern soldiers. Cognitive dissonance isn't a new thing.
Yes modern ideas of chivalry are just that, modern. I have no problems believing that they, and their culture believed they lived a 'good' life.
- garmaine 8y agoYou survive wars by being chivalrous. That’s where chivalry comes from—it does not mean protecting women and children or holding open doors or whatever nonsense. It was a medieval code of warfare where nobility were not killed but held for ransom no matter the circumstance. Landed families could participate in sanctioned warfare with relatively little personal risk. Their peasant soldiers would die, and they may lose their lands, but they themselves were likely fine. Chivalry died with the invention of the longbow because death now rained down indiscriminately from above.
- benj111 8y agoWikipedia dates the longbow to paleolithic times, so I'm not sure chivalry died with it. And judging by the effectiveness of the longbow you seem to be making my case for me That chivalry doesn't win wars. That said I do agree chivalry was useful for making the battlefield survivable. It still existed in some form until the world wars with 'gentlemanly conduct', I'm not sure it was ever internally consistent.