3 ms·
Evolutionarily speaking, what is the impetus for this? It isn't like a dangerous situation, where you would benefit from remembering it for the rest of your li
by benj111 8y ago
Evolutionarily speaking, what is the impetus for this?
It isn't like a dangerous situation, where you would benefit from remembering it for the rest of your life, despite only experiencing it once.
Also it isn't like remembering something that you do every day.
The closest approximation I can think of is something that happens seasonally, it is probably beneficial to remember how to harvest the berries of the bonga bonga tree, despite not having seen them for 51 weeks.
Is long term memory not fine grained enough to bother differentiating between 'a year ago' and '20 years ago'?
- mrob 8y ago>It isn't like a dangerous situation, where you would benefit from remembering it for the rest of your life When you first start it feels dangerous. It's much easier to evolve a feeling of danger, caused by things like unexpected body movement, than to evolve an instinctive ability to calculate the true danger.
- benj111 8y agoRe remembering a dangerous situation, I was thinking more 'that hairy thing with the pointy teeth just ate my friend, better stay away from it' Cycling seems rational? In a way that adrenaline wouldn't help you remember. Think of soldiers doing drills. They aren't in danger when they actually do the drill. The idea is that they do it automatically when they are I danger, rather than just freezing. I'm not sure actually shooting at new recruits while training them would lead to effective training, but we could try it :).
- toast0 8y agoFalls and near falls are certainly enough to get some adrenaline flowing. Riding through the woods or particularly rough roads where your wheels scoot to the side on obstacles is exciting too. My understanding of basic training comes only from popular media, but some of the drills at night without warning to enhance the simulation of danger. Fear of the drill sergeant may work too.
- lexicality 8y agoThese memories are stored in the centre of the brain and thus presumably evolved well before sentience. Learning how to climb a tree or swim in a fast river are very important survival skills and the ability to not forget them would give you an advantage.
- benj111 8y agoGood point. I'm having trouble imagining cave men taking swimming lessons but yeah the mechanism seems to fit.
- Someone 8y ago(Warning: layman’s comment) I would guess part of it is that this needs fast feedback loops. That means it gets controlled from ‘lower-level’ parts of your nervous system, possibly (¿partly?) from the spinal cord (like the patellar reflex https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patellar_reflex https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patellar_reflex), rather than from the brain. Those parts of you nervous system have to be fast, and may be less flexible because of it, increasing both learning time (you can learn what you have to do to cycle in seconds: “OK, I’ll sit there, put my hands there, my feet there, keep my balance and make these movements, but actually learning how to do it takes a lot longer) and forgetting time. I also guess that makes cycling and walking so relaxing as activities. You’re doing work, but can let the more cerebral parts of your brain wander around without giving much attention to what’s going on (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mind-wandering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mind-wandering). Of course, that’s dependent on environment. A walk in the park is more relaxing than crossing Times square, and cycling on separated cycle lanes more relaxing than the hell of navigating between cars, because, in both cases, your ‘higher brain’ must attend to the situation.