2 ms·
Very eloquently said. A trend in the DL/ML research community is the strong and vocal distancing from discussing or approaching the problem of General Intellig
by AndrewKemendo 8y ago
Very eloquently said.
A trend in the DL/ML research community is the strong and vocal distancing from discussing or approaching the problem of General Intelligence or anything which might look like sci-fi AI. You can see this with aggressive railing against silly robots like Sophia and others, which have gotten press.
I think this is warranted, and understandable as the field is so scared of another AI winter.
On the other hand it leaves the field without a real progress vector. Especially given that broadly, ML research isn't scientific as such. In other words, the vast majority of "research" is not around hypothesis testing and using computing to test questions about intelligence. Rather it's demonstrating increments of improvement within very narrow computing tasks.
I make that point not to diminish the work or results, as they've obviously been astounding. Rather, to point out that unlike basic or social sciences research it's not attempting to surface fundamental truths (theories, laws etc...) about some natural or emergent phenomena, but rather continuously benchmarking on narrow tasks - often without prior reference. Now that ILSVRC is gone, I'm wondering what kind of benchmarking is going to emerge as the new vector for the field.