2 ms·
You're unfamiliar with them because there aren't any. At least none that I have seen which have any kind of history of research or applications. See my discussi
by AndrewKemendo 8y ago
You're unfamiliar with them because there aren't any. At least none that I have seen which have any kind of history of research or applications. See my discussion with Gary here: https://twitter.com/AndrewKemendo/status/1068908423956312071 https://twitter.com/AndrewKemendo/status/1068908423956312071
Ng wasn't even really saying it in a way that is explicitly making the case - at least not enough to cause this kind of fracas.
It's a bit unfortunate really, and I'm not sure what's driving the animosity or aggressiveness around this issue. While I agree with Marcus, I don't think anyone actually disagrees - largely because nobody is arguing what he is trying to address. Marcus has built a strawman and is tilting at Windmills a bit.
- woodandsteel 8y agoI have a question. Marcus is saying that to get AGI, or at least get a lot closer to it, we need to combine ML with symbolic manipulation. Do you agree or disagree?
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoHis position is actually too poorly designed to really evaluate. However I think it's a reasonable argument to make that a General Intelligence may use some form of a symbolic system. I'd even accept the claim that General Intelligence would require some form of expert systems to cross the threshold. So in that sense, combining DL with Expert Systems, other symbolic methods or approaches like Bayesian Causal analysis is probably required.