3 ms·
> The idea that say a startup has time to audit every line of every dependency is absurd. Even a big business can’t do that. This may sound strange, but once t
by pessimizer 8y ago
> The idea that say a startup has time to audit every line of every dependency is absurd. Even a big business can’t do that.
This may sound strange, but once tech companies actually had to either write or buy all of their software, and if they didn't have a contract in place that made someone else responsible for its quality, they were. So, basically, the world was absurd.
The way FOSS works is if users agree that a common good is important enough to invest in, and then they all benefit more than they would if they invested alone; it's anti-competitive. Free (and Open Source) software should be thought of as "free as in beer" i.e., the next round is on you. If you can't audit every line, audit some of them, or pay someone else to do it. Coordinate to get code coverage. If you use a project that is inadequately covered, you're responsible for everything that goes wrong.
If you don't even know what libraries your project depends on, how could that ever be thought of as anyone's fault but your own?
- the8472 8y ago> Coordinate to get code coverage. This may be a central part of the issue. It's a coordination problem and creating common knowledge. Each corporation might be willing to pay to have some bits of their dependencies audited as long as others cover other pieces. But to do that they need to be able to announce the audit result and scan their dependency trees for pieces that are not audited and pick from those. You'd also need some common standards what constitutes an audit and the lawyers would probably want some limits on liability so results should be considered as best-effort or whatever. There are no conventions and social protocols in place to support this.