9 ms·
Inside the British Army's secret information warfare machine
- MichaelMoser123 8y agoNow how is this different from a Russian or Chinese troll factory? All these puppeteers playing political technologists, bother. Are they really thinking this stuff is changing hearts and minds over to the right cause?
- giobox 8y agoIt’s often not even a battle for hearts and minds en masse. Given the polarised state of many western democracies today it’s often just a few percent or less of the electorate one would need to influence to affect outcomes. Given this, with sufficient investment and scale, it seems alarmingly doable to me.
- scottlocklin 8y agoI think the dirty secret of all this is that it really doesn't matter much. I remember when Usenet was a thing; basically, nation states are acting like people did when they were first exposed to arguing on Usenet.
- walshemj 8y agoIT does if your caught up in a riot - you have heard of the lynching's in India caused by social media. And a few years ago in the Rwandan genocide old school radio was a key instigator, 1 million dead in 100 days
- MichaelMoser123 8y agoGreat explanation, now all this action seems to be targeted at young people between twenty and thirty (the older ones are watching TV) Fascinating, correct me if I am wrong: so young people these days are no longer glued to the tube, so they do 'grassroot media' to attract them, but by doing so they now openly make propaganda for the state. Or maybe it is because young people are no longer tied into the consensus (as memories of the new deal/welfare state are all gone by now), so they have to spend more effort to integrate them. Go figure. (and i saw the movie 'Ralph Breaks the Internet' with my kids the other day, nice movie if you read between the lines)
- akiselev 8y agoWe've actually come full circle from "ok Grandma, I won't believe everything I see on TV" to "grandma, stop sending me articles about how Hillary had Seth Rich murdered from totallynotfakenews.mk"
- MichaelMoser123 8y agoAnother question: what will be the editorial slant/bias of these guys when a close election has to be decided? What kind of oversight exists for these guys? Are they only accountable to their managers at GHCQ ?
- KineticLensman 8y ago77 Brigade [0] would be operationally managed by military commanders (Joint Forces Command [1] for a specific op), not GCHQ. [0] https://www.army.mod.uk/who-we-are/formations-divisions-brigades/force-troops-command/77-brigade/ https://www.army.mod.uk/who-we-are/formations-divisions-brig... [1] https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/joint-forces-command/about https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/joint-forces-com...
- blinky1456 8y agoI imagine they are semi open because maybe they exist only to counter things like for example: Imagine we were using our armed services to provide purely humanitarian assistance in a theater(is that the right word?). And Russian troll farms are pumping out news saying we are invaders, and actually killing and kidnapping people who try to get help from them. This directly puts our guys on the ground at even greater risk. Even people at home and in allied countries start to believe it. It makes life harder for them in the future in many ways, politically and global politically. It could be they exist purely to dispel actual myths/lies, and are kinda like the snopes of armed forces news. At least this is what I hope the intention is..
- timthorn 8y agoThe simultaneously flippant and serious answer is that the Queen sorts things out. For any one constituency, a dead heat will be decided by drawing the short straw, and then it's up to Parliament to come up with someone who can command a majority.
- hnmonkey 8y agoI don't think the Queen actually has any power to do anything anymore. She's more of a figurehead and I would guess is nowhere near deciding anyone's fate (if she ever was) much less deciding political races.
- jf- 8y agoDepends on what you call the right cause. If you’ve joined the British army we can assume you think the UK’s interests are the right cause. If everyone else is doing this they can’t very well not it too, it would be like not having an army when everyone else around you does.
- Veen 8y agoFrom my perspective, as a British person, the difference is that this is being done by British people to support British interests. As a person who lives in Britain, and by extension the west, and who supports the general values on which my society is based, I'm not interested in relativist comparisons. If the information war must be fought, I'd like us to win it.
- booleandilemma 8y agoAnd as an American I’d rather the British be doing it than the Russians or Chinese.
- justtopost 8y agoAs an american, I don't see a difference. The UK has been as blatantly evil as the rest. I would argue russians enjoy more freedom. I think this UK favoritism is simply racism by another name.
- dqpb 8y agoAs a skeptic, I don't think any of you are real people. Just bots optimized to ddos my attention.
- Veen 8y agoWhy racist? Russia has interests and an agenda it pursues. The west including the US and UK have interests and an agenda they pursue. Conflict is all-but-inevitable. Choosing a side is not racist; it's rational. You can, of course, choose to support the other side because you think the West irredeemably evil and that Isis or Russia or China are morally superior. Many have taken that path. Most people, though, choose their communities, their families, their friends, and their country.
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoAs another British person I'm unconvinced that "British interests" include the interests of most British voters. Historically we've seen the British state infiltrate and influence organisations that it considers hostile to it. https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/ng-interactive/2018/oct/15/uk-political-groups-spied-on-undercover-police-list https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/ng-interactive/2018/oct/... What stands out is the trivial nature of most of these groups, which surely fall squarely within a general democratic right to assemble and protest. What also stands out is that right-wing groups don't seem to have had anything like the same level of oversight. So if - hypothetically - the military and/or GCHQ ran a campaign to influence a British election, or a public referendum, would that align with "British interests" or not? This isn't a hypothetical. It's obvious from the comment sites of most newspapers and also from posts on FB interest groups that industrial-level opinion-shaping is being attempted. If it's originating from hostile foreign powers, the UK's cyber response seems inexplicably ineffectual. If it's originating from closer to the home, that's clearly a non-trivial problem for our "general values."
- mlb_hn 8y agoOne difference is the Russians have massive malware networks available from their criminal operations they can use for certain information operations, e.g. https://www.trustwave.com/Resources/SpiderLabs-Blog/Bedep-trojan-malware-spread-by-the-Angler-exploit-kit-gets-political/ https://www.trustwave.com/Resources/SpiderLabs-Blog/Bedep-tr.... I have not seen anything on western governments doing anything close to that sort of thing.
- jonnydubowsky 8y agoWith the evidence pointing to vast numbers of state agencies around the world engaging in this type of information warfare, do you think it better that democratic nations do nothing in response? What would be an alternative or more effective method of defending against the Russian and Chinese troll farms? I'm not endorsing these tactics, and wonder if we are already in a situation where there is a threat of mutually assured destruction? Doing nothing in response seems to lead to even worse outcomes then the admittedly unsavory alternative.
- kaffeemitsahne 8y ago>What would be an alternative or more effective method of defending against the Russian and Chinese troll farms? Not believing everything you read on the internet.
- jnurmine 8y agoYes, indeed. It might also help to understand how the operation works. The method seems to be, based on my understanding of analyses in the Finnish media about how the "troll factory of Saint Petersburg" operates: 1. amplify suitable existing events/movements with fake accounts spreading supporting posts, 2. use advertisements or rumors to create suitable new openings for 1, then do 1. The main purpose is to amplify messages that are aligned with the political aspirations of the Russian Federation. Further legitimacy is obtained when a "serious news site" (usually other Russia controlled media like RT) publishes something about the subject. The idea becomes something more legit and more plausible, even though it might have begun as an intentionally fabricated lie. The rest is taken care of by gullible people who absorb the message without much thinking and then spread it further, especially when the message fits their image of or desired state of the world. So basically the Russian troll factory is an astroturfing organization, but instead of pimping a product, they pimp emotionally loaded social media sentiments that support political goals.
- nyolfen 8y agothat’s just media
- dragonsky 8y agoI think the scary thing about nation states trying to covertly influence each other is that many of these states are supposed to be allies, or at least friendly. They certainly are not at war. I naively believed the Cold War was over, obviously it has only changed its methods, to where influence over a countries people is the weapon and it's being used widely.
- chrisseaton 8y agoWhy do you say ‘nation states’? The UK is the classic example of something which is not a nation state.
- jacquesm 8y agoGive it a few years and the UK will no longer exist. The largest remainder will most likely be called England and the rest will have broken away.
- Veen 8y agoThat's possible, but I don't think it's likely. Scotland voted to stay in the UK when given the choice. That choice is not likely to be given again in the near future. Wales wouldn't flourish on its own. Northern Ireland, maybe, but also unlikely -- plenty of Unionists will fight to the death to remain part of the UK.
- jacquesm 8y ago> Scotland voted to stay in the UK when given the choice. That was before the 'leave' vote.
- Veen 8y agoYes, and Scotland may want to leave the UK and join the EU on its own terms, but that is almost certain to fail. Many EU countries, especially Spain, have regional nationalist movements. They do not want to encourage regional partitions by letting breakaway regions join the EU. Scotland is better off in the UK than outside on its own.
- KineticLensman 8y agoThey are hardly 'secret' - they have their own web site! [0] [0] https://www.army.mod.uk/who-we-are/formations-divisions-brigades/force-troops-command/77-brigade/ https://www.army.mod.uk/who-we-are/formations-divisions-brig...
- blinky1456 8y agoYeah, but they are no longer on twitter...Well, that we know of.
- fredley 8y agoInteresting that this comes out at the same time that a Russian journalist triggers a security alert filming outside their base of operations: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-46420486 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-46420486
- orbital-decay 8y agoOP article came out a couple weeks before that happened. It's likely they followed a Wired article to dig up some dirt, or to add 2 and 2 and get 999.
- abdulhaq 8y agoGiven that it is very likely that the UK military seriously considered a coup in the seventies (https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2006/mar/15/comment.labour1 https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2006/mar/15/commen...) it seems foolish to place the job of political story placement and disinformation with them.