2 ms·
Well copying in itself helps them gain some more skill and 'mutate' the designs with knock-offs if they are doing it with any level of understanding. I've heard
by Nasrudith 8y ago
Well copying in itself helps them gain some more skill and 'mutate' the designs with knock-offs if they are doing it with any level of understanding. I've heard accounts of Soviet copying being caught done as very verbatum to the point of leaving in designer signatures in a computer chip's unused circuit mask space, and an extra rivet hole in a wing (although to be fair given the sheer expense it is probably worth adding an unneeded hole than finding out that the hole was a fix for some obscure issue that could cause the plane to crash).
One systemic advantage is an anti-oligarchic one in that it prevents abusing the IP incumbent from abusing their position too greatly - often seen with prescription drugs. If they charge so much that it would be cheaper to just reverse engineer it and start producing it locally (not a cheap or easy task) - well that is what they are going to do, thus encouraging more reasonableness.
The third potential advantage is highly situational and an ironic opposite effect of the reduce R&D incentive. If the market is hot enough to sustain it a constantly changing market is a working strategy to encourage maximized innovation - if anybody can just copy the previous one in say a year but a superior product can be made by then it means that a constant cycle of innovation keeps them on top. As opposed to a protected situation which would allow for innovating only when someone else might catch up on their own or the protection expires. While the later would be better for them it would be worse for the world if say Moore's law behavior applied only every decade.
- _cs2017_ 8y agoActually the last advantage is very convincing, especially in the technology industry. The equilibrium R&D investment level depends in a very complicated way on the relationship between your market share at any point and the entire history of your investment. I won't be surprised if that equilibrium level goes up as IP protection period shortens. Of course, there is no objective way to decide what the socially optimal level of R&D investment is in the first place. I guess we can just assume that the higher the better, as long as the economy still produces some food :)