Well then, someone is lying here, because these two sides of the story seem to be in direct conflict with each other; at least one side’s claim must be false.

Well then, someone is lying here, because these two sides of the story seem to be in direct conflict with each other; at least one side’s claim must be false. FWIW, an anecdote from my experience: Of all the companies I’ve ever applied to, Google is the only one that required unofficial course transcripts and GPA. P.S. Starting a comment with “Ummm?” doesn’t really add much value to the discussion.