3 ms·
No matter whether you agree with them or not, asking someone to sear their conscience is one of if not the most corrosive things you can do to them and to human
by andrewflnr 8y ago
No matter whether you agree with them or not, asking someone to sear their conscience is one of if not the most corrosive things you can do to them and to humanity at large. The author probably didn't mean it quite that way, but that's what this post is asking of googlers.
Don't do that.
- pishpash 8y agoGoogle pulling out was one of the best and last of Google's "Do No Evil" opus. Whatever the true reasons, with that decision, you can say something about Google as a company and you can say something about China as a country. One example is all that is needed sometimes. Without that, you get moral equivalency and all the attendant devolution.
- vokep 8y agoIs it though? I definitely disagree with the author, but I don't know if they're asking really to sear conscience as much as offer the perspective of their own conscience. They are not asking googlers to be ok with everything China does but are arguing that Google removing itself from China causes more harm than good. They're wrong (I think) but, its perfectly reasonable to make such an argument if one believes it.
- andrewflnr 8y agoThese Googlers' conscience is telling them that collaborating with a repressive regime's repression is wrong. OP is asking them to collaborate anyway. QED, honestly. I know the intent is what you've outlined, but I'm saying that's not as important, here anyway, as the conscience angle.
- pas 8y agoThis is probably a mismatch of ethics. Some are deontologists (say no to collaboration on principles) some are consequentialist/utilitarian. However it's hard to assess the long term effect of this on Google and other Google users. That's the real question. Okay Google builds DragonSpy. Okay, please make it work for Vietnam too says Vietnam, then me too says Putin, Venezuela, Iran, Turkey and so on. As long as dictators are forced to block it wholesale, people have a signal. (Even if it is propagandized and spin as a good thing, let's say for economic protectionism.) When dictators can fish for their enemies, people have a problem.
- andrewflnr 8y agoIt's more than that. Deliberately creating the environment where people ignore their conscience is always a huge mistake, beyond the particular issue. As a species, we need to be paying more attention to our consciences, not less.