3 ms·
Did you see the diet? Another commenter posted it [1], and it has 132g carbohydrates. Doesn't seem like a small load (though it may be an improvement over what
by SilasX 8y ago
Did you see the diet? Another commenter posted it [1], and it has 132g carbohydrates. Doesn't seem like a small load (though it may be an improvement over what they're currently doing!). At 4 cal/carb [2], that's over half the diet's calories.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18571000 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18571000
[2] https://www.nal.usda.gov/fnic/how-many-calories-are-one-gram-fat-carbohydrate-or-protein https://www.nal.usda.gov/fnic/how-many-calories-are-one-gram...
- bad_user 8y agoAFAIK the standard American diet has about 250g of carbs. 132 grams of carbs is about the standard recommendation for T2 diabetes. That said these recommendations are bullshit. If you have diabetes, you have an insulin problem and it's best to minimize it, so you need to eat the minimum amount of carbs you can get away with, prioritizing the complex carbs with fibers (e.g. spinach and other greens). Btw, a low calories diet can work even if higher in carbs, because: 1. by losing weight insulin sensitivity goes up afaik 2. at 800 grams per day, that's not much to eat, so those people are probably fasting for much of that day That's just a guess, but how you distribute your meals also matters just as much as what you eat.
- isoskeles 8y agoHow much of those carbs are fiber? I'm trying to find the direct quote and see if more information is there. Although, given the description of it includes "fruit juice", I am guessing it is a lot of sugar, which seems weird but I can't admit to know enough to say this is bad. I'd be interested in the efficacy of this sort of diet when applied to a large mass of people as opposed to a very low carb diet. The NHS can "prescribe" these diets, but people may not follow them. It's possible that having a moderate amount of carbs (as sugar) in the diet will actually decrease the chances of a person going in the complete opposite direction and binging on sugar after they get sick and tired of a very low carb diet. I'm curious if they study that effect and "risk" of diets.
- village-idiot 8y agoNot a lot. The recommendation is mostly liquid calories (think milk and juice), so this is mostly going to be high glycemic fructose, not a lot of fiber.
- isoskeles 8y agoYeah, sounds like you're right. Edited my post with a long diatribe! The "juice" part doesn't instill confidence.