2 ms·
Tracking the index on your own would be more than a full time job. You could do it automatically, but that just reinvents the fund The S&P500 had 500 stocks. D
by mcguire 8y ago
Tracking the index on your own would be more than a full time job. You could do it automatically, but that just reinvents the fund
The S&P500 had 500 stocks. Do you want to vote ~1.5 times a day?
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 8y ago> Tracking the index on your own would be more than a full time job. You could do it automatically, but that just reinvents the fund That reinvents funds ... without the problem of accumulating all the power in a few hands, which was exactly my point? > The S&P500 had 500 stocks. Do you want to vote ~1.5 times a day? No, and why would I have to? For one, many index funds don't vote on many stocks either. But more importantly, the point is to unbundle voting rights from the portfolio management aspect. Just as that doesn't mean that you have to manually track an index, it doesn't mean you have to manually vote either, does it? You can just delegate it to some group that you think represents your interests, and you could do so selectively. If some group wants to get some particular company to change something and you support that, you could just delegate the voting rights for that one company to that group.
- foolsgold 8y agoThat's like saying that you could launch your own space station and live in orbit, but you'd just be recreating NASA. I worked for Vanguard and worked with the people who run the index funds, it's just a little harder than it looks.