26 ms·
AO is still a raytracing technique to create non-physical based depth. Ex: I'm pretty sure Voxel-cone tracing will still "unnaturally" darken corners, as pointe
by dragontamer 8y ago
AO is still a raytracing technique to create non-physical based depth. Ex: I'm pretty sure Voxel-cone tracing will still "unnaturally" darken corners, as pointed out in the discussion.
Just because it "isn't real" doesn't dismiss the use of AO. AO improves contrast and likely improves the time it takes for humans to see the edges of objects.
I don't think AO is used in movies that try to emulate reality. (ex: Iron Man's suit, Spiderman's suit, or other 3d effects). But cheaply increasing the contrast and edges of characters may remain important in video games, at the cost of being less realistic.
Then again, video games don't usually look hyper-realistic anyway. There's just not enough space in the budget for that yet. Video Games can likely benefit from better sub-surface scattering for example...
------------
The only "fully real" technique is to use a 16k+ HDRI environment map for lighting. The technique doesn't seem to work for enclosed spaces though.
- gmueckl 8y agoAmbient occlusion was originally invented as a computationally lightweight way to add depth cues based on the assumption of uniformly diffuse illumination of the whole scene. This works quite well in animated movies where we perceive this as part of the stylized look. But this is not physically correct.
- skohan 8y agoMaybe, but the question is why you would do a less accurate approximation when you can easily do a better one? For example, before true HDR lighting in games was a reality, Half Life 2 faked iris adaptation by placing a brightly colored quad at the end of an exit from a dark tunnel into an outdoor space, and fading it out as you walk toward it, as if the player's vision is adapting to the brightness. Now the same effect is achieved by rendering to a floating point buffer which has much more dynamic range that can be displayed, and compressing that range in post-processing with parameters based on the light levels of the area the camera was focused on in the previous frames. It's much more faithful to real life, and it's less work than the faked solution from Half Life 2. You might be right that AO adds value beyond enhanced "realism", but it could also easily add to a long list of graphics techniques which look jarringly bad when compared to the more refined technique which replaces them.
- vokep 8y ago>video games don't usually look hyper-realistic anyway Eh, they don't have to, but there are certainly many games already where a slightly blurred screenshot could be mistaken for real.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoIt would depend on what the screenshot contained, but in all but the best-case scenarios, I think you'd have to use a lot more blur than what I'd consider "slight".