10 ms·
Is it time for us to simply accept that it's inevitable that, at some point, everything will be hacked, and hacked often? Should we be focusing our efforts mor
by crazygringo 8y ago
Is it time for us to simply accept that it's inevitable that, at some point, everything will be hacked, and hacked often?
Should we be focusing our efforts more on how to make "identity theft" (i.e. fraud) more difficult, even when someone knows all your data?
Something more tied to your physical self, whether 2FA or something else?
- freehunter 8y agoEveryone who knows about security already accepts that everything either already is hacked or will be hacked eventually and no one can stop it. There's a famous quote and I'm not sure if it's originally from former FBI Director Robert Mueller [1] or former Cisco CEO John Chambers [2]: "There are two types of companies: those that have been hacked, and those who don't know they have been hacked." [1] https://archives.fbi.gov/archives/news/speeches/combating-threats-in-the-cyber-world-outsmarting-terrorists-hackers-and-spies https://archives.fbi.gov/archives/news/speeches/combating-th... [2] https://www.networkworld.com/article/2952184/cisco-subnet/john-chambers-10-most-memorable-quotes-as-cisco-ceo.html https://www.networkworld.com/article/2952184/cisco-subnet/jo...
- brootstrap 8y agomi gringo. i accepted this fact a few years ago hah. If your sh aint hacked already, you better believe our Googlie Amazonian Apple overlords are listening to every word we say, logging every keystroke in browser etc. Have our overlords hacked our own life to steal personal data? Kind of seems like it. Oh well we are just one drop in bucket of millions of hacked americans. I'll just keep going with the flow, loading up my retirement funds and hoping the world dont crash in the next 70 years so i can see my family grow, retire, and spend time with the wifer
- Latteland 8y ago70 years? Are you 10 years old?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoThe writing style would certainly suggest so.
- brootstrap 8y agoNope, I am a supposedly successful and functional american adult working a 9-5 like many of yall here. I said 70 years because my life and interests extend beyond just myself. I want 70 years of growth of my net worth to pass on to my children and give them all the gifts that have been given to me.
- nkkollaw 8y agoJesus, I really hope you're not American (like you imply) and English is not your first language.
- brootstrap 8y agoYup I wrote that sittin at my office desk in midwest with a jupyter notebook and pycharm open cranking on unit tests =) Lord help us if someone doesnt use perfect prose on the HN! If it makes you feel any better my code is worth 8 figures to some random suits, for better or for worse.
- nkkollaw 8y ago> If it makes you feel any better my code is worth 8 figures to some random suits, for better or for worse. I would love to read the comments. // shit ain't working before, I just changed that bitch just deal with it :-D
- brootstrap 8y agohaha! Bro you already know my code is self documenting, my comments ARE the code.
- nkkollaw 8y agoYour code is THE code. :-D
- darkerside 8y agoSeems like it. Bank vaults are difficult to get into, sure. But they're especially difficult to get into without being detected. Go ahead and force your way in if you want to. You most likely won't have long to enjoy it since you've been witnessed in person, by security cameras, and are now carrying marked bills. Perhaps in the digital world as well, intrusion detection is more valuable than intrusion prevention?
- throwaway5752 8y agoI don't know what your background is, but IPS is a huge deal already. Tens of billions of cumulative market cap in the space. Your physical "bank vault" analogy doesn't model the threat very well for many reasons. If you happen to know how to solve this, though, you will be incredibly wealthy.
- sbov 8y agoThe digital world does not require my physical presence which means that even if you detect me, odds are you can't even identify, much less apprehend me. Bank robbers have no such luxury.
- darkerside 8y agoMost things are impossible before you figure out how to do them
- pc86 8y agoSo your argument hinges on changing basic limitations we currently have in monitoring online access?
- jwr 8y agoI hope that after several GDPR fines companies will start considering gathered data as a liability, not an asset and collect less to begin with.
- SlowRobotAhead 8y agoSomething I was taught awhile back relating to IT, “Data is toxic”. Get rid of it when you can, as often as you can. You’re right. These companies should absolutely have to weigh the cost of keeping data because they overestimate their ability to keep it safe.
- naravara 8y agoThe most valuable data is just necessary to do their business though. Our financial and identity information are the things we hold most dear, but that's also exactly what we need to exchange in order to engage in commerce.
- guitarbill 8y agoTo a degree, yes, which is why it has to be secured properly, with state-of-the-art systems and engineering. I'd venture a guess to say this wasn't. But until we hold executives personally and retroactively responsible, nothing will change.
- cr1895 8y agoBut must it be kept indefinitely?
- mamon 8y agoNot indefinitely, but typicaly IRS or similar institution will require you to store all the transaction records for, say, 5 years. Which, from the purpose of hackers trying to steal your data is as good as "indefinitely".
- mLuby 8y agoYou could say the same thing about corporate lawbreaking. It's likely given enough time and employees, but that doesn't absolve the company of its responsibility and liability. We need tough, enforced penalties for data breaches, plain and simple. It's a negative externality, just like pollution, and so can only be controlled by regulation.
- dennisgorelik 8y ago> It's a negative externality, just like pollution No. Your leaked data does not hurt me. So it is NOT like pollution. If you do not like your data on the internet - do not give it to companies you do not trust. > can only be controlled by regulation Your claim is wrong. Companies behavior is controlled by customers demands. The balance between security and convenience -- is not an exception here: customers demand define where that balance is. There is no need for the government to intervene in this case.
- harshreality 8y agoI really want to know why identity verification can't incorporate better technology, since driver's licenses and passports and such have been upgraded but are still non-interactive (from the user's perspective) and can't prove identity remotely. i.e., instead of the traditional "what are the [last 4 of] your SSN, and/or we'll tell you three things that may or may not be in your credit history and you have to fill in the blank on each of them"... ...why not just use 2FA? You give everyone a TOTP code on a separate card but tied by the government to your SSN, passport number, and state ID. You provide a government mobile app that they can use if they don't want to use a 3rd party one. When some third party wants to verify your identity, there would be a heavily secured, simple, autited government server that you'd use the app to auth to (ssn + TOTP), returning a temporary auth code/passphrase, stored for 1 day and associated with your SSN. You give that temporary code to the third party, which then verifies that temporary auth code or passphrase with that same government server. You could have an additional voice phone channel to get the temp codes, for people without smartphones. If your TOTP code card and device are both lost or stolen, you visit in person to get a new one just like normal. Anyone who sees the card can impersonate you, but you shouldn't be carrying it around or waving it around, and even if stolen in individual cases, the scheme eliminates mass identity theft. U2F could be an option, for anyone with a u2f-capable hardware security key or smartphone, but I'm not sure about mandating u2f because compatible hardware has a non-trivial marginal cost.
- megous 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EIDAS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EIDAS Went into force a few months ago.
- mindslight 8y agoBecause the cost of "verifying identity" is a feature! The easier it is, the more frivolous uses of it there will be - imagine basic forum websites deciding the easiest way to cut spam is to demand real world IDs. Google's new practice of requiring of a phone number to make an account would look tame in comparison. This very case is already an example of overreach. The only reason a hotel needs someone's identity is in case they trash the room and skip out. There is absolutely no reason that it should have been kept after checkout, except that we've been groomed to expect this surveillance based on payment cards being similarly broken. I can see the possibility for reasonable progress in the EU, where a government ID could carry rules that it couldn't be involuntarily used for business purposes (and assuming that would actually last). But in the US, the government will mandate some base system and then let companies abuse it ad infinitum - even social security numbers are already way too much.
- jrue 8y ago> Is it time for us to simply accept that it's inevitable that, at some point, everything will be hacked, and hacked often? I disagree. I’d take the Economists route, which is looking for the incentives that drive motivation. If companies were held to a higher standard of accountability, imagine how many would beef up their security. For decades, security researchers have been poking fun at how ridiculous some of these sites are at handling security, and nothing ever happens. Now, imagine if there was severe economic accountability to a company that was hacked. Perhaps payouts to each person affected (in this case, to all 150m). I imagine you’d see security become a top priority very quickly at most companies.
- nkkollaw 8y agoIn Europe you have GDPR, there are huge fines for stuff like this.
- ams6110 8y agoHave any fines actually been levied and enforced?
- nkkollaw 8y agoDefinitely. Here is an example: https://www.insideprivacy.com/data-privacy/portuguese-hospital-receives-and-contests-400000-e-fine-for-gdpr-infringement/ https://www.insideprivacy.com/data-privacy/portuguese-hospit.... There are also many, many more examples for smaller companies that get fined 5000-20000.
- Choco31415 8y agoYes, there have been some enforcements already: [0] https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/first-gdpr-sanction-in-germany-fines-flirty-chat-platform-eur-20-000/ https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/first-gdpr-sa... The Flirty chat app is fined for leaking 808,000 emails to the tune of 20,000 EUR. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18531588 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18531588 The Cuddly chat app is fined for using plaintext password storage to the tune of 20,000 EUR. (No hack known as of yet?) [2] http://fortune.com/2018/11/27/uber-eu-data-hack-fines/ http://fortune.com/2018/11/27/uber-eu-data-hack-fines/ As foreword, this occurred under older privacy laws and not quite GDPR. Many sources agree that GDPR would increase fine sizes in a repeat event. Due to a data breach at Uber exposing 57 million people's records, they were fined 600,000 EUR by the Netherlands and 385,000 GBP by the UK. [3] See nkkollaw's comment below/above.
- SilasX 8y agoHas any state's DL database been compromised? The US government's passport DB?
- ams6110 8y agoMost likely yes, we just may not know about it.
- ryanlol 8y agoDBs containing essentially all US citizens like Accurint/Seisint have been compromised in the past https://www.theregister.co.uk/2007/03/08/lexis_nexis_hacker_jailed/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2007/03/08/lexis_nexis_hacker_... https://phys.org/news/2013-09-lexisnexis-breach-earlier-year.html https://phys.org/news/2013-09-lexisnexis-breach-earlier-year... I'm preeetty sure they source DL data from some state DMVs.
- sneak 8y agoYou're only thinking of transactions. Physical location history (which hotels they frequent, and when) is damaging enough to HNWIs. Name + location + timestamp is sufficient to prove physically dangerous when leaked. What we need are more options to transact anonymously. This "show ID for everything" culture needs to stop.
- cheeseomlit 8y agoMaybe, but there's a legitimate fear that this thinking will eventually lead to everyone being required to be implanted with a microchip to participate in the economy
- cmurf 8y agoPast time. There are way too many people comfortable with giving companies date of birth, passport and social security numbers, as forms of ID. And therefore the sane and aware people who don't want to give up that information, are left as non-participants because they are the minority. And therefore I think there needs to be law making it illegal for certain personal information to be stored. Marriott can sufficiently confirm my identity by getting my name, address, phone number, and a credit card number. The latter can be used to verify the former via a 3rd party, the issuer of the credit card. And this verification doesn't require storing the credit card number. Anyway, these companies are bad at their job as evidenced by the breach happening. And I definitely think we're past the time where it should be illegal for companies to even ask for passport numbers, DOB and social security. A phone company, a hotel, need none of that. They just want it. Big difference.
- late2part 8y agoLike a chip in your forehead or right hand?
- xur17 8y agoI'm starting to wonder if it would be a good thing if the data from one of these broad hacks was widely distributed, forcing companies to come up with a better way to verify "identity". If companies knew that there was a database that everyone has access to with all the data you need to signup for new sources of credit for 50% of US residents, there would be a very strong financial incentive to actually fix the problem.
- ken 8y agoI see two possible readings of your comment, which are almost opposites. One is that we should all learn to deal with this much data about ourselves being exposed. The other is that the root cause here was how much data they collected about us in the first place. I really don't understand why so many companies think they need so much information about me. Or even if they do need it, why such disparate data as passport numbers, credit card numbers, email address, gender, and home address would be stored in the same database. Is there a law that requires hotels to collect all this data? I've stayed at some cheap motels where they glanced at my driver's license and accepted a couple of $20 bills, and I got a key, and that was the entire transaction.
- netwanderer3 8y agoAgree. The Infosec field is a rabbit hole. It's a cat and mouse game. As long as it's run by human, everything is bound to be hacked eventually.