4 ms·
But evolution doesn't find optimal solutions in the wild. Invasive species prove that. They were a solution that would have worked but evolution never managed
by im3w1l 8y ago
But evolution doesn't find optimal solutions in the wild. Invasive species prove that. They were a solution that would have worked but evolution never managed to create locally.
- GuiA 8y agoCan you elaborate a bit on your comment? I am not sure I quite understand the distinction you are trying to make. Much like “weeds”, when referring to plants, is a distinction that is only relevant in the context of human agriculture, so it is for “invasive species”. All life is, by definition (reproduction), invasive.
- pif 8y agoI think he's talking about animal and plants that prosper in a region they could reach only due to human intervention (think: trans-oceanic or trans-continental travel).
- faceplanted 8y agoNo, what he's saying is that evolution doesn't always produce optimal species for the environment, if a species is so invasive as to out compete the native species, then clearly _it_ is more optimal than the one that literally evolved there. Meaning Evolution doesn't find optimal solutions unless it has the right starting configurations.
- empath75 8y agoOptimal for _what_? It makes no sense in the context of biological evolution.
- Drdrdrq 8y agoOptimal for survival in the given environment. However the worth of solution depends on other solutions (organisms)... Interesting way of looking at the problem.
- coldtea 8y agoEvolution never finds "optimal solutions" (except by happenstance). It just has to reach some solution that works and allows the organism to survive and reproduce. Optimal-ity is not a factor.
- bsmitty5000 8y agoI have no expertise in the subject, but my intuition says this doesn't hold because the wild you're dealing with entire ecosystems, where everything is evolving together. Through the shared evolution they come to some state of equilibrium. Invasive species, evolved in entirely different ecosystems, have adaptations that allow them to take advantage of foreign ecosystems only because they didn't have to evolve those traits alongside competition. But, like I said, no expertise, just my initial reaction to your comment.
- jibal 8y agoNatural evolution is not directed and so cannot be seen as solving anything.
- gnulinux 8y agoIt is optimizing survivability, which is a moving target as it depends on geography, ecosystem etc, so yes it's not running an optimization algorithm in a traditional sense since the function is changing as the algorithm runs. But locally (i.e. inside a geological era) species can be seen as solving certain physical/chemical problems e.g. locomotion, poison, electrocution, flight etc.
- nikki93 8y agoI think our narrative surrounding survivability optimizes for some types of things (things that have coherent identity over time). eg. "a snapshot of a tree in time" lives less long than "a tree" (many snapshots-in-time together) And I think certain problem descriptions and solitions are better fitted to such survivability descriptions. But I'm not sure if there is an independent thing than the observer-language complex optimizing for anything. Like I feel like there is an inherent observer bias in the way survival is being defined, it feels more like "observable." Like in the local time of a tree snapshot (from its perspective), time may feel different than from ours observing it.
- gnulinux 8y agoThere is a single common ancestor of all living things today. This organism survived objectively better than any other organism of its time (unless it's the very first organism ever, which is very unlikely). Same thing goes for e.g. the last common ancestor of mammals vs an animal living this time that doesn't have an extant grandchild. I think it's possible to define survivability objectively using a little graph theory.
- Drdrdrq 8y ago> There is a single common ancestor of all living things today. Are you sure about that? Viruses too? (depends on your definition of "living" of course) To clarify: I don't know if there is or isn't, I just don't think anyone does.