4 ms·
> Australians are used to the higher price of food, have been trained not to expect table service, have a rigorous set of laws around underpaying trainees and t
by taneq 8y ago
> Australians are used to the higher price of food, have been trained not to expect table service, have a rigorous set of laws around underpaying trainees and teens, have endemic "under the counter" wage fraud to avoid taxes and the minimum wage, and don't feel morally obliged to tip their expensive waiters and waitresses.
Woah. One of these things is not like the other ones.
(As an Aussie, though, the tipping thing just seems weird. It's nice to tip a little for really good waitstaff, but if doing so means they get a pay cut on their hourly wage then that's bogus. Paying your staff poverty rates because you expect them to live off tips is like paying your police force poverty rates because you expect them to live off bribes.)
- rdlecler1 8y agoThat’s a false equivalency.
- winston_smith 8y ago"False equivalency" is a nonsense phrase. Analogies aren't true or false.
- TomMarius 8y agoThat is a very wrong metaphor. A waiter literally works for you during the meal you tip for. A policeman is not supposed to.
- taneq 8y agoI guess this is a perfect illustration of the difference in perception, because I wrote that thinking "the waiter works for the establishment (for pittance) and you tip (bribe) them for better service (nicer treatment).
- AllegedAlec 8y ago> A waiter literally works for you during the meal you tip for. No, they work for the restaurant. Their job is to relay orders from me to the kitchen and bar.
- TomMarius 8y agoAnd you think that a human alternative to conveyor belt is worth more than the current minimal wage? You got the whole thing wrong, and you managed to insult every waiter and waitress in the process: A waiter does so much more than that. They generally take care of you - they help you to choose your places to your liking, undress, seat, they recommend food based on their expertise and clever judging of their client, and so on - they generally take care of you, and that can and is (and should) way more complex than being a human conveyor belt. The actual argument is whether this job is a job done to the customer or to the restaurant (because it can be thought of as a whole package service or their image). Americans think that the waiter will help a client more if the client is the person who pays them - literally, with actual cash changing hands. Other people don't. I'm from such country and sometimes it leads to horrendous results, however most of the time it's OK - yeah, "OK", never great, so I definitely can see the point the Americans have. Overall, IMO there are places where human staff is appropriate (fine dining places, brewery, upclass cafe...) - tipping is appropriate here. Of course there are places where the point is to obtain a plate and eat everything as soon as possible so you can be gone - but IMO people shouldn't serve the plates at these places.
- taneq 8y agoThey don't do any of that. Waitpeople aren't magical happiness-producers, they're just pleasant and make sure your glass is refilled and ask if you need anything. Which would just be my Australian experience talking if it hadn't been exactly the same when I was in the U.S. Waitstaff aren't magical concierges of euphoria, they're just nice and bring you more coffee. As you say, the real difference is whether the waitperson is an employee of the restaurant who is paid by them to look after you, or whether they're an independent contractor who resells the kitchen to you at the table as a service. The service produced is generally the same, IME, but in the U.S. model you have to negotiate with two different contractors while each is trying to push the costs onto the other. Ugh.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoCute metaphor. But waitpeople can't actually set their price. They don't say "You want more coffee? How will that affect my tip?" In a tip economy they are what they are - poor supplicants begging for your scraps. They have no power over the kitchen nor much over you, since they get their feedback after they've made their 'pitch' not before.
- levosmetalo 8y ago> A waiter literally works for you during the meal you tip for. As a European I would say that US type waiter works against me. When I'm trying to eat my meal, I don't need some stranger to come to my table every two minutes to ask me "how are you?", "is everything ok?", "do you need something more?". It's just annoying. I can't eat, I can't talk personal talks with friends, when someone is around me trying to annoy me all the time. I can't raise my head or look around because the waiter would come to annoy me again. And in the end, that annoyance comes to your table and expects 15-35% of the price for the annoyance "service" he gave you during the lunch? Sorry, but when I'm in restaurant, I just want to order food or drink and be left alone. If I need something I'll raise my hand and wait. What's the issue in waiting for a guy to come, he's a waiter after all ;) If the waiter comes quickly after I raise my hand (usually to pay the bill) I would round the bill to the next full €, and that's it. That's why in Germany you have 3-5 times less waiters serving the same number of people in restaurants, they are paid a livable wage, and you pay what you see in the menu, without a need to add 50% for VAT and service tips.
- TomMarius 8y agoI know how it works in Europe, I'm European. Why should it work like we want it to all around the world? Haven't we exported enough of our culture? USA is a different place, let it be.
- piva00 8y agoI'm not an European (as stated on my other comment, I'm Brazilian) and was also quite bothered by servicing in the US. I wish there was a way to signal that I don't want to be bothered but even when I voiced this feeling to a waiter in NY he was still coming around unasked.
- guiriduro 8y agoWhat's wrong with exporting best practice? Underpaid waiters bugging customers on the expectation that with enough extra coffee they might get their aspirational wages paid, customers who have to calculate the cost of their meal plus service charge... in what world is that efficient? Restaurateurs - just pay your staff properly, waitstaff - don't bug the customers; there you go - european advice for free.
- strken 8y agoIt's actually sort of related. Because US waitstaff get so much of their pay in tips, the industry commits fraud by under-reporting them, while in Australia the industry actually pays its staff, and so commits fraud by under-reporting hours and headcount. I'm sure prices will rise a bit until everyone figures out how to rip off the taxman again.