5 ms·
I've used Asana in a couple of projects and actually like it for its simplicity and ease of doing things like copy pasting multi line issues from a spreadsheet,
by jillesvangurp 8y ago
I've used Asana in a couple of projects and actually like it for its simplicity and ease of doing things like copy pasting multi line issues from a spreadsheet, text file, or chat; easy editing with multi select; and similar features that make the product feel more similar to a spreadsheet than an annoying issue tracker where every click results in modal dialogs with OK buttons and other cruft. I hate stuff like Jira with a passion and it doesn't do anything for me that I 1) need 2) Asana does not do in a way that is more convenient.
That being said, it's not 1.5B dollars cool and that kind of multi billion valuation creates unrealistic expectations that cannot possibly be fulfilled by staying humble and focusing on just what Asana does best. So, this kind of investment smells like a kiss of death. I fear the worst here in terms of layering on features nobody wanted, and attempts to make the product more appealing for the masses, etc. Is this going to be an actual IPO or a lazy acquihire by some company in need of an issue tracker?
- fjp 8y agoI use it at work and as far as I can tell it's just a web app where you can move cards around. I do like the fact that it's simple and snappy and doesn't have a shitload of options and features no one wants that cause it to load super slow (Cough cough Jira) However, some basic workflow enforcement would be nice (Cards marked done when you put them in the "done" column) In its current state it seems like it could be cloned in a week. Edit: cloned in a day if you wanted just the functionality and not a cute little UI
- mylons 8y agoweekend project
- pscarey 8y agoIt's easy to make a (poor) copy of the product. It's hard to execute the idea, take market share, and capture customer revenue. Asana blogged this year about 50k organisations, 6 quarters accelerating growth [1]. Back in 2015 they blogged mentioning the heating up 'enterprise collaboration market'. There's countless office tools, diagramming tools, collaboration tools. Even in software there's more CI systems than I can count. My guess is there's a big market which the VCs think is accessible to Asana in a way it's fundamentally not to a competitor. Combined with big growth it makes sense. [1] https://blog.asana.com/2018/09/asana-company-updates-2018/ https://blog.asana.com/2018/09/asana-company-updates-2018/
- nerdponx 8y agoTaiga.io is a pretty good facsimile, but Taiga tries to incorporate too many of JIRA's Agile-related non-features rather than sticking to the basics. There is no good alternative (right now).
- fipple 8y agoCloned in a day? I could clone it in four minutes
- paulcole 8y ago> I use it at work and as far as I can tell it's just a web app where you can move cards around. Are we adding Asana to the HN list “I’m Not Seeing Why This Isn’t Just a Weekend Project?” which includes: Twitter, Facebook, and DropBox among many others.
- andyroid 8y agoOne persons “basic workflow enforcement” requirements is another persons “shitload of options and features no one wants” :) It seems everyone has their own idea of what basic enforcement entails, and JIRA is pretty much ~20 years of trying to please everyone in this regard.
- _RPM 8y agoIt seems that it’s fashionable to hate JIRA on this forum. I’m not sure how one can be so religious about a workflow management tool.
- BigJono 8y agoIt should be pretty obvious to anyone that's used both JIRA and it's competitors that it's a piece of shit. It's missing basic functionality that competitors have like live updates (I guess I'll just telepathically guess when my teammates have made an update and hit F5), it's got basic UX problems that everyone else seems to have solved just fine (opening outbound links in a new tab etc), and their new redesign appears to have done fuck all to make any of it better. I don't care how many features it's got for BAs/PMs to wank over. If the basic usability isn't there, the devs won't proactively participate, which means they'll either be forced to (incurring a big hit to morale), or they'll use other tools like Trello or physical boards to organise instead, and you end up with multiple sources of truth and synchronisation problems. How it's ever become so popular is a mystery to me. I wouldn't inflict it on a team of my worst enemies.
- aik 8y agoInteresting. These seem like relatively minor issues to me. We switched from Asana to JIRA about a year ago. We spent about 2 years using Asana, and I hated working with it daily. JIRA is very far from perfect but like it many times more. We have significantly better understanding of where our team is and our projects now, and we scoured the web for every way to use Asana we possibly could find. To each their own... One of the things that bothered me the most about Asana was how slow it was (also a UX issue).
- 8y ago
- itronitron 8y ago>> (Cards marked done when you put them in the "done" column) Well now we know how they pitched for the $50M.
- submeta 8y ago> ... that kind of multi billion valuation creates unrealistic expectations that cannot possibly be fulfilled by staying humble and focusing on just what Asana does best. So, this kind of investment smells like a kiss of death This! Exactly what happened to Evernote IMO. Otherwise excellent product almost killed by the expectations by the 1b valuation.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bearcobra 8y agoWithout insight into their internal numbers how do we know it's not 1.5B cool. They've been around for 10 years, so I can see it being the case that they've built something profitable
- turdnagel 8y agoPretty sure the CEO says they're close to profitability, but not, in the article.
- ummonk 8y agoValuations in the low billions of dollars for a SaaS company with a relatively simple product aren't that unusual. The closest parallel for Asana is Smartsheet, which IPO'd earlier in the year and has a market cap of ~2.6 billion. There are companies with even simpler products that are worth even more - Docusign is worth 6.5 billion for example.
- puranjay 8y agoTrello sold for nearly half a billion with a product that is arguably simpler than Asana and a monetization process that was far less aggressive. So I'd say that the 1.5B valuation isn't too ambitious
- harshalizee 8y agoDocuSign is not even remotely as simple as you think. Notice how there's no one else in the same space. Microsoft tried and failed and ended up with DocuSign integrated inside Outlook ( the only third party integration I believe). The nightmarish regulation of signatures is complex enough, let alone the doc management system.
- neilsense 8y agoHelloSign and others are in the same space and seem to be doing just fine.
- manigandham 8y agoEchoSign was one of the originals, and there is also SignNow, HelloSign, and many other smaller vendors. It's becoming rather commodity for most.
- raiyu 8y agoHave to be careful comparing mature companies which show consistent and predicatable growth with those that are still early in that cycle. While the revenue growth the last couple of years for Asana is obviously on an uptick you have to be careful that the growth is really a precentage not an absolute value. If they are growing 50% that's awesome, but if instead they are growing $25MM, from $25MM to $50MM, to $75MM, to $100MM that is a completely different story. You need another dot on that plot to see which one it is. Overall the valuations for SaaS companies are definitely well ahead of revenue but early on in a company's history that's ok as there is a lot of future growth potential. However, listing that graph without a Y-axis label for revenue implies that it is well below $100MM in revenue and most likely that last plot is around the $50-60MM line. So definitely an aggressive valuation for the time being.
- hendzen 8y agoAsana was founded by Dustin Moskovitz. He has enough money to personally fund them for many years. It's not going anywhere.
- puranjay 8y agoImagine being so rich that founding a $1.5B company only adds marginally to your net worth
- itronitron 8y agoor just imagine being an early employee at a $1.5B company and watch it only add marginally to your net worth
- vadym909 8y agoValuations in Silicon Valley are not based on some rational price to earnings multiple. It is based on what investors think a large monopoly like SAP, MSFT, GOOG, CRM, etc would pay for it. Even the 8 times revenue is not a good benchmark anymore. The buyer will have umpteen ways to justify the price- new users, complementary products, etc. Just see SAP buying travel expense app for $8B.
- hyperpallium 8y agoI thought dropbox was a really cool idea, well executed both in engineering and marketing... but not 7.1 billion really cool. A product that straightforwardly saves businesses time/money is easy-to-buy. Company valuation is just a few steps further. Primary danger is competition.
- bfung 8y agoYep, simple comparable: Atlassian's market cap is 19.981B [1], with $874.0 million for fiscal year 2018 [2,3] Now, Atlassian sells other things beside jira/confluence (the asana comparable?). It also has a github-like comparable and also a CI/CD type thing. There's other small details, but as a rough estimate, make your own conclusions from the numbers. 1. https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/TEAM?p=TEAM&.tsrc=fin-srch https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/TEAM?p=TEAM&.tsrc=fin-srch 2. https://investors.atlassian.com/financials-and-filings/quarterly-earnings/ https://investors.atlassian.com/financials-and-filings/quart... 3. https://s2.q4cdn.com/141359120/files/doc_financials/2018/Q4/TEAM-Q4FY18-earnings-release-(1).pdf https://s2.q4cdn.com/141359120/files/doc_financials/2018/Q4/...