5 ms·
> Whose job is it/should it be to get that infrastructure built, and on what timeline? The new residents, so, by proxy, the developer putting the apartment blo
by vkou 8y ago
> Whose job is it/should it be to get that infrastructure built, and on what timeline?
The new residents, so, by proxy, the developer putting the apartment block in.
Of course, the developer immediately starts grousing about regulation, and excessive fees, and apparently, this is the reason for why we can't have sub-$400,000 apartment units.
> Obviously it's not reasonable for a private contractor to have to build a school addition for each housing block (or is it?)
It is reasonable for them to pay the city enough money to construct the infrastructure necessary to serve the new density they are adding.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- helen___keller 8y agoinfrastructure in sprawl costs more per capita than in dense urban developments. If these people will move to the same city anyways, maybe the city should be subsidizing the cost of the infrastructure because it’s cheaper to provide it to a big building on an existing street than it is to a new subdivision down the road
- maxsilver 8y ago> infrastructure in sprawl costs more per capita than in dense urban developments. (snip) it’s cheaper to provide it to a big building on an existing street than it is to a new subdivision down the road Unfortunately, even if you divide the costs per person, it's still often cheaper to get 40 people new water lines in say 20 average suburban homes, than it is to get 40 people new water lines in say, one building in Manhattan. Infrastructure costs do not scale evenly per mile. The capital costs in infrastructure are rarely the actual wires or pipes, it's the installation and maintenance labour. Which are considerably more complex and more expensive in dense urban environments, than it is in the sprawl. There are plenty of downsides to sprawl (it's a waste of land, for instance). But sprawl is nearly always cheaper (even after removing all subsidies), that's kind of the whole reason sprawl exists in the first place.
- Karrot_Kream 8y agoThe problem is, you're comparing a Manhattan high-rise to 20 single-family homes. Price/performance tends to be mid-rise apartments, which look like duplexes for the most part. These mid-rise apartments are cheaper per-capita both capital wise and maintenance wise than sprawly single-family homes. Sprawl exists because of zoning codes, not because of a market equilibrium. If you're interested in the phenomenon, read https://www.strongtowns.org/the-growth-ponzi-scheme/ https://www.strongtowns.org/the-growth-ponzi-scheme/ about the Growth Ponzi Scheme.
- maxsilver 8y ago> you're comparing a Manhattan high-rise to 20 single-family homes. That's generally what people mean by "Dense Urban" vs "sprawl", yes? You could replace "Manhattan" with "Chicago Loop" and it would be the roughly identical. > These mid-rise apartments are cheaper per-capita both capital wise and maintenance wise than sprawly single-family homes. They aren't, sprawly apartments (like duplexes, or low-mid-rise apartments) are roughly equivalent to costs as sprawly single family homes, and dense apartments are more expensive. This gets confusing, because sprawly apartments (like duplexes or low-rises) are usually lower quality and lower maintained than nearby single family homes, and therefore are cheaper. But if you brought the SFH down to that lower level of maintenance, they too would be cheaper in a similar way. (And similarly, if you brought those low-density apartments up to the quality of nearby SFH, they would be slightly more expensive). > Read Strong Towns I have, many many times. They get promoted on HN on a literally daily basis. Strong Towns is a fun blog to read, but unfortunately, Strong Towns is simply wrong sometimes. Their understanding of suburban finances is one thing they are semi-routinely incorrect on, they assume most suburbs are only financially viable if they continiously grow -- and while this is true for some, it is not common for most. The Growth Ponzi scheme they mention, while true for a handful of suburbs, does not apply in any way to 75% or more of suburbs across the US. Don't take my word for it. Most municipalities budgets are public record (they should all be, really). Look up one near you, and see this for yourself.
- maxsilver 8y ago
- AngryData 8y agoIf it is taking people from actual rural areas (and not just suburbs), rural areas can grow much of their own food, heat their homes with renewable wood, draw their water from a well, shit into a drain field. The only infrastructure is power and roads and the roads are needed regardless because rural areas produce resources that cities require to exist. Be it crops, milk, meat, coal, iron, copper, sand/glass, stone, concrete, ect.
- masonic 8y agoheat their homes with renewable wood This is increasingly regulated against, and we wouldn't want more if that even if unregulated.
- xapata 8y ago>> Whose job is it/should it be to get that infrastructure built? > The new residents Surely it's not their sole responsibility. New residents boost the local economy, so the old residents benefit.
- stale2002 8y agoThose apartment buildings are paying the same property taxes as everyone else. That I'd what property taxes are for. To pay for stuff like this.
- masonic 8y agopaying the same property taxes as everyone else Not per capita, they aren't.