6 ms·
> this was already known. ADHD is a neurodevelopmental disorder You're sounding like: "being a certain age is a disorder". > Requiring younger children to si
by raverbashing 8y ago
> this was already known. ADHD is a neurodevelopmental disorder
You're sounding like: "being a certain age is a disorder".
> Requiring younger children to sit still and pay attention may be a much more challenging task since their brains are actually less developed. Thus, they more easily get pushed over the diagnosis line compared to their older classmates.
Teachers who can't control kids (and to be honest, school requirements have been getting broader) will want to give them a pill as it's easier.
Reminds to be seen what is the effect of such medicines on kids under development.
- genkimind 8y agoFrom what I've read, increased development in the PFC is one of the effects of stimulants. They are prescribed for PFC brain injuries for a reason.
- johnh3o3 8y ago> will want to give them a pill as it's easier. Well yea, sometimes pills help people. > Reminds to be seen what is the effect of such medicines on kids under development I mean adderall (amphetamine) is pretty well studied. Yea they have some adverse effects (stunted growth, not good if you have a pre-existing heart condition, etc.) but as with literally every medicine, the decision to take them or not take them requires you to balance the adverse effects (which can be monitored) with the adverse effects of the illness. It frustrates me so much to see people just flippantly ignore the actual underlying problem that the pill is supposed to be treating as though it's "healthier" to not take the pill. Depressed people can kill themselves or if they don't their lives are pretty crappy. ADHD can cause all sorts of real problems. If you think pills are just an "easy way out" then that's really insulting to people who actually benefit from using them and really don't want to have to deal with judgement from other people who clearly have no idea what it means to suffer from a serious mental illness (ADHD can be debilitating). If you do happen to suffer from a serious mental illness and do not take pills, that's great (maybe?) for you, but that doesn't mean that's the "right" way. In fact I had two parents with mental illnesses that took that route and it was really not fun growing up with that, though it was a great lesson in how not to deal with mental illness.
- jacobolus 8y ago> the actual underlying problem For many the “actual underlying problem” is that forcing small children to sit and focus on unmotivated externally assigned busywork while being passively monitored by a stressed out and outnumbered authority figure is a cruel waste of time. Many of the same kids would be just fine if their day consisted primarily of free play, especially outdoors.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- saulrh 8y ago"Requiring every building to have a ramp instead of stairs wastes everyone's time and money. Many of the people that need them could get along in crutches long enough to use the occasional building." People like you are why I went undiagnosed until I was 27. Everyone around me thought that I just needed to focus harder and take better notes and get some exercise. Hell, I thought those things too, which meant I was dealing with burnout and depression on top of everything else. It ruined grad school and it's going to take me decades to catch up with my life goals. You should find a way to contribute that doesn't involve sweeping generalities that make it impossible for people with real problems to realize that they have them.
- dorchadas 8y agoI don't think that's what OP was saying at all, though. I took his comment as saying that we often expect too much structure from kids at too young of an age, then diagnose the worst of them. For example, at age 7 I was still bursting with pent-up energy and often didn't want to sit still, especially if I was bored. My first grade teacher once taped me to my chair to try to get me to sit still during reading time (I was reading at a higher level, and "See Spot Run" bored me to tears). She and my kindergarten teacher probably could have pushed for an ADHD diagnosis, but they didn't because I think they realized that we often shove kids too young and expect them to adapt to a fairly rigid structure too quickly. Now, I'm not saying that nobody has ADHD and that it's not a horrible problem for those who do. Sometimes, I really do wonder if I might have it, though I tend to think against it. But for those who truly do have ADHD, I understand that medicine is needed, and that the sooner we give it, the better off those students can learn. I just feel that OP was saying we test for it way too young, and expect way too much out of kids when testing for it.
- jonhendry18 8y agoTeachers don't diagnose or prescribe.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- roguecoder 8y agoThis sounds like "kids who can't read the white board should just sit closer or look harder". Yeah, some kids can't read the white board because they are sitting way far back or haven't figured out their letters yet, but some kids need glasses. The reason professionals make diagnoses instead of HN commenters is because they can tell the difference between "needs more phonics" and "can't see".