9 ms·
Bee-brained
- perpetualcrayon 8y agoun-bee-lievable
- fiblye 8y agoReally interesting article. It's seeming like the more we learn about other life, the more we realize not much separates humans but a couple of thumbs and some decent dexterity. I wonder if someday we'll reach a point where we recognize consciousness in most animals and think it was ridiculous that earlier people didn't see such an obvious fact. Just like how "common knowledge" just a few decades/years ago was that babies and crustaceans couldn't feel pain, but it'd be bizarre for anyone to claim that today.
- jjtheblunt 8y agoIt's not that they don't recognize it, it's that the knowingly don't want to believe it, authorized by religions to kill animals for food and mistreat them in general.
- LitFan 8y agoIt's a stretch to say that religion 'authorizes' us to mistreat/eat animals. Animals eat other animals. We're animals, so we do that, too. If anything, religions largely promote treating animals properly, because they're some form of gods' creatures.
- ajuc 8y ago> It's a stretch to say that religion 'authorizes' us to mistreat/eat animals. "Be fruitful and multiply, and fill the earth and subdue it; rule over the fish of the sea and the birds of the air and every creature that crawls upon the earth." Of course people would do it anyway, especially when they had no other choice (nowadays we could live without exploiting animals, it would even be cheaper and more ecologic - but before we knew chemistry and biology we had at least some excuses). But at least Bible-based religions clearly legitimize abuse of animals, and treating animals as mindless things that don't have feelings nor rights. Even now in my country ecologists/vegans are one of the groups considered enemies of "natural order" by influential religious media (Rydzyk media-empire in Poland for one example). It's not an accident that animals don't have souls according to Catholicism.
- LitFan 8y agoUnfortunately, those groups, like many others who intend to control people with religion, cherry picked an example that fits their rhetoric. The bible is often contradictory, and in it you can also find these: > 'He that killeth an ox is as if he slew a man' (Isaiah 66.3) > 'For meat destroy not the work of God' (Romans 14.19-21) > 'A righteous man regardeth the life of the beast' (Proverbs 12.10) Christianity doesn't represent the majority of religions (~31.5%). Islam, Hinduism, and Buddhism all advocate for animal rights (~45.3%).
- ajuc 8y agoIslam is Bible-based as well (to some point). And their halal butchering practices aren't particularly humane by modern standards, even if at some point in the past they were.
- nine_k 8y agoThe key thing humans got is replacing the genetic evolution by memetic evolution, aka culture, powered by structured communication aka speech. This allowed for organizations above the Dunbar number, and very quick evolution of behaviors without constantly killing and re-spawning physical bodies. Some advanced animals, like wolves, have something resembling a passing of cultural knowledge: they teach their young how to hunt particular prey, and this may differs seriously between packs and types of prey. But they lack speech, so they can't pass more complex ideas. Cetaceans are said to have consciousness not unlike humans'; maybe they have speech and an advanced culture; we don't know. But they lack means of manipulation and live mostly floating above abyss, so they don't have a material culture and technology. Quite possibly it's not an exceptional intellectual capability that singled out humans among comparably intelligent animals, but the (proto-)speech ability. The advances in intelligence then followed, being evolutionary beneficial.
- maxwell 8y ago> Cetaceans are said to have consciousness not unlike humans'; maybe they have speech and an advanced culture; we don't know. But they lack means of manipulation and live mostly floating above abyss, so they don't have a material culture and technology. You refuted your own argument. Sounds like it's more about the "material culture and technology", which started with control of fire. No living species other than Homo sapiens harnesses fire.
- nine_k 8y agoYes, fire was a key thing in the development of technology, and then (a few hundred thousand years later) domination of the biosphere. What I mean that animals which did not develop technology may have other kinds of advanced culture, such as that we would recognize as culture, e.g. in social organization and explanation of the world ("philosophy"), and/or art — it they have a capability for structured communication and thus capable to pass more and more complex knowledge across generations.
- starbeast 8y agoAustralian raptors do - http://www.bioone.org/doi/10.2993/0278-0771-37.4.700 http://www.bioone.org/doi/10.2993/0278-0771-37.4.700
- maxwell 8y agoLots of animals have opposable thumbs: https://animalsake.com/list-of-animals-with-opposable-thumbs https://animalsake.com/list-of-animals-with-opposable-thumbs The only thing that makes the Homo genus unique is control of fire.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoAnd our genetic code. And schools and fire departments and lasers.
- eplanit 8y agoExactly. And libraries, moon/Mars/deep space exploration.... It amuses me when there's an article that recognizes a similarity between humans and other species, many jump onto the "see, they're _just_ like us" meme. What I'd be intrigued by is if there is any other species (is there _any_?) that has, century over century, via pure self- and collective-determination, advanced their state of being, achieved new capabilities, live in ways completely different than their ancestors, etc. I'm not including genetic adaptation or evolution to suit an environment -- I mean self-driven advancement. Seems we're quite unique, in that regard.
- sdegutis 8y agoRight, that's called rationality. All other creatures are irrational, they act only on pure instinct, even if that instinct is sophisticated, such as the primates seen sharpening sticks for hunting, or the birds that drop hard shells into traffic so that cars crack it open and they get to eat what's inside, or the ways bees self-organize. Sophisticated, but still just instinct. We're the only rational creatures.
- theli0nheart 8y agoYou’re joking, right?
- 8y ago
- richsinn 8y agoFurthermore, this kind of stuff always makes me wonder if/when other genus will eventually evolve into "intelligent" beings (with "intelligent" being loosely defined). The Homo genus evolved around ~2-3 million years ago; homo sapiens came about ~250K years ago. What's not to say that 2 to 3 million years from now, there'll be some other intelligent species from other genus branches? It always tickles my brain to think about this. Also relevant: https://io9.gizmodo.com/5780020/if-humanity-went-extinct-what-species-would-replace-us https://io9.gizmodo.com/5780020/if-humanity-went-extinct-wha...
- nickspacek 8y agoI've had the same thought. Unfortunately at the rate we wipe out other species I don't know that they'll get the chance! But when debating conservation efforts for various species it does seem like there is the possibility that on one hand we could be allowing the extinction of a species on the cusp of "intelligence".
- bananatron 8y ago"...biologists now suggest that consciousness-like phenomena might not have evolved late in our history, as we previously thought. Rather, they could be evolutionarily ancient and have arisen in the Cambrian era, around 500 million years ago."
- Koshkin 8y agoThe bees are highly social, and it is possible that it is primarily this fact that “lifts” their mental power into the realm of consciousness. Being part of the socium has been proven to be critical for a human to be, well, human. What is interesting, though, is that while the social life is lifting the bee, it appears that it often moves the individual human mind in the opposite direction.
- pavel_lishin 8y ago> The bees are highly social, and it is possible that it is primarily this fact that “lifts” their mental power into the realm of consciousness. As far as I understand it, a theory of mind is a hard requirement for consciousness - you understand that other beings have minds, then you model them, then you turn that in on yourself, and the loop is closed and voila, you develop tools and culture and anxiety.
- pavel_lishin 8y agoI'm probably not qualified to say this, but just about every example of consciousness in bees and flies that they described could just as easily be explained if they were automatons.
- rladd 8y agoActually, all examples of consciousness can be explained as if we're all automatons. There's nothing we do which isn't produced (so far as we know) by physical (and therefore mechanistic) functions of the brain and body. "Consciousness" is something that we experience, but it's not required to explain anything at all that's observed.
- pavel_lishin 8y agoFair enough; it would have been more accurate for me to say that bees don't necessarily have a conscious experience based on what we see.
- chronolitus 8y agoQuoting my previous comment: "I think it also useful to semantically separate cognitive consciousness (i.e. Knowing and expressing the existence of your thought processes through arguably higher, more abstract thought processes - which might even go on recursively - knowing that I know that i am conscious, etc) from the externally unmeasurable 'conscious experience', (i.e qualia, the awareness of sensory or thoughts at the most essential level, 'seeing' what one sees, etc). One could imagine a living being with one but not the other, for example qualia without cognitive consciousness (if I had to guess, I would imagine this experience to be similar to being drugged to the point of having no internal monologue, no complex thought process, but keeping your sensations and vision, etc, or being a barely-sentient animal in purely instictual mode of thought and action) The opposite, cognitive consciousness without qualia - a.k.a the philosophical zombie - or a computer which can argue the existence of it's thoughts without feeling them is, I gather, a more controversial state of being. What I find interesting is that in separating the two 'consciousness's, the former ends up taking almost all of the importance and the latter none - anything which can be externally measured ends up in the first category (which is a computable logic process), which leaves very little of utilitarian/evolutionary/algorithmic importance in the second. However, in much discourse about consciousness the latter takes a disproportionate role (i.e fear of losing your unmeasurable consciousness when teleporting, etc, though the cognitive consciousness, being by definition a logical and measurable process is theoretically preserved)" In this case although the article, to get quick views, appeals to our love for the mystical attributes of the 'conscious exprience phenomenon', the paper actually studies the (in my opinion much more) interesting empirical characterisation of the level of cognitive consciousness in insect 'brains' - i.e., how elaborately their software models its own processes.
- monocasa 8y ago> Yet, for the most part, Descartes did not think very highly of the inner life of nonhuman animals. ‘[T]he reason why animals do not speak as we do is not that they lack the organs but that they have no thoughts,’ Descartes wrote in a letter in 1646. That's borderline whitewashing his thoughts and actions on the matter. He did stuff like nail his wife's dog to a board and vivisect it to prove that it couldn't "truly" feel pain.
- gambler 8y agoBees are one of the reasons I think the current metrics for "smartness" of AI are misguided and that we are very, very far away from AGI. Bees are capable of learning, planning, communication, prediction and at least some form of abstract reasoning. And it can operate sensibly in contexts very different from its normal environment. All of that with just 960,000 neurons. No artificial neural networks show anything close to this level of flexibility. Does it really matter whether a bee is better at any of those tasks than "average" or "best" humans? Clearly, once flexibility is achieved, other capabilities can be improved upon iteratively, because that's exactly what happened in nature. And yet I don't see any researchers looking at how many different tasks their specific AI can accomplish, instead of how well it can accomplish a particular one.
- TrainedMonkey 8y agoThis is a simplistic view of what is going on. That complexity is not produced by 1e6 neurons alone. Rather it is a combination of a neural net embedded in a biochemical harness. The harness interacts not only with individual bee's systems, but also with environment and other bees (via pheromones, etc.) I do agree with you that we still have much to learn in neural network design (or more generally distributed algorithms). For example distributed systems are notoriously bad at state machines (or sequencing in general). One of the ways biological systems handle sequencing is via multiple signaling layers with different time constants (e.g. pheromones vs neurons). On the other hand deep learning systems I am familiar with just throw more parameters at the problem, obviously this scales poorly with the sequence length.
- awinter-py 8y agothis article could be evidence that they're zimboes (because the author is convinced they have a real inner life)