3 ms·
Conceding your every point for the sake of argument: what use is any of that to 'Haunted' right now? It's hardly going to come as a surprise that adult life inv
by throwanem 8y ago
Conceding your every point for the sake of argument: what use is any of that to 'Haunted' right now? It's hardly going to come as a surprise that adult life involves tradeoffs; she's speaking from a place where she has belatedly recognized that fact, and feels as if she's made every one of them wrongly. If the purpose is to help 'Haunted' - or those reading along who find 'Haunted' painfully relatable - make more of the years ahead of her than she has of those behind, where do you see this sort of thing making success in that purpose more likely?
- SCAQTony 8y ago"Man is condemned to be free; because once thrown into the world, he is responsible for everything he does." — Jean Paul Sartre, (French existentialist)
- throwanem 8y ago'Freedom is what you do with what's been done to you.' — apocryphally also Sartre, but really who cares? Wisdom is wisdom. To your quote: responsibility, sure, but its corollary is authority, and they exist together in precisely identical degree. Just as we bear the burden, if it is one, of the stories we write of our lives - we do nonetheless retain the ability to write whatever stories of ourselves we choose. Sartre may consider that a condemnation. I can imagine no more liberating conception of life.
- yters 8y agoPerhaps advising other young women from her own experience? Then those years will not have been wasted. On the other hand, if no one learns from her mistake and makes the exact same mistake, then her years will have been wasted.
- throwanem 8y agoCertainly. But I am specifically asking 'simonsarris just whom it is he thinks he's helping here, and how, and why.
- someguydave 8y agoHe’s helping Haunted by telling her the unvarnished truth. She can still do something positive with her life but many doors are now closed for her.
- hayd 8y agoor will be in another few years.
- throwanem 8y agoI understand that is what he thinks he’s doing, yes.
- squish78 8y agoWhat answer are you fishing for?
- throwanem 8y agoOne that at least makes a credible attempt to justify privileging brutality, as in the sort of 'brutal honesty' on display here, over kindness. I have no preference over whether such a justification proceeds from pragmatism or principle, but I would like to see one attempted.