8 ms·
Frankly I stopped reading the moment the book was mentioned. It feels off and insincere.
by Tade0 8y ago
Frankly I stopped reading the moment the book was mentioned.
It feels off and insincere.
- kempbellt 8y agoI would think the same thing, if the book wasn't relevant to the topic being discussed. Providing a sincere response, and self-promoting are not mutually exclusive. It's more like "Hey! I wrote a book on this exact issue. I really hope it helps"
- barberousse 8y ago> It's more like "Hey! I wrote a book on this exact issue. I really hope it helps" Except that's your notion and not what Polly was doing with their book mention in the article. There it served as a way to kinda say, "Hey, I also share some insecurity issues with you, caused this by book I'm touring on right now, and oh, here's the link to it". There was no other nudging of Haunted to read the book.
- danso 8y agoThe book is relevant to the topic being discussed, because the author talks about it to describe how she herself -- purportedly a successful published author -- has to fight off feeling inadequate, even though she's being paid by her publisher to travel cross-country to promote her book. Take out the mention that she's on book tour, and you no longer have a frame of reference about her self-shame.
- hateful 8y agoI did the same thing. In my mind I went "oh, there it is" and closed the tab. That's a shame, since the first half was quite harrowing.
- 5874-4b22-a4e0 8y agoFirst part was probably embellished anyways. Anyone can make up a two part sob story style q&a for promotional purposes.
- bartcobain 8y agoFrom the promotion part, it just got obnoxious, egocentric and insincere.
- Pica_soO 8y agoYes, to be honest, it feels like it caught the author of the reply off guard and downed him/her into a existential crisis, and to fend that demon off - the protection spell of success, the mantra of self-promotion was cast. Two lonely people meet in the public plaza, one walks home without its facade. But at least she is not as lonely as before. As lonely as the shining success story on the soap box. That pride in whatever-you-are-preach is so generic, so rehearsed, im sure, the author could have thrown this to a AA meeting or a junkie with the monkey on its back, without flinching.
- jimijazz 8y agoI can totally understand this, and it seems that a lot of the blog posts that make it to the top of HN are in some way self promoting the writer's work (be it music, IT consulting, their web-product, their music, etc). I guess it is a hard balance to strike between self-promotion and good content. Perhaps if the writer could be more open about the promotion stuff in the beginning of the article it wouldn't feel insincere.