3 ms·
You make it sound like there's a choice between whether the country should be run by "ignorant peasants" or "smart people looking after everyone's interests".
by pavlov 16y ago
You make it sound like there's a choice between whether the country should be run by "ignorant peasants" or "smart people looking after everyone's interests".
Maybe it's not in the best interests of the country to have 700 million peasants? Most Western countries have about 2% of population employed in agriculture. Can China continue to keep its agricultural population politically stuck in the early 20th century?
- chadp 16y agoThis is a discussion about India and China, not the West and either. So should India keep allowing expansion of their peasant classes / caste? Should the "untouchables" (lowest caste / class) continue to be allowed to have 7 or 8 kids in India? Is creating huge numbers of more poverty stricken people in the lowest caste, the best for India? Will they make it even up one caste level (let alone "middle class")? Both countries are far from perfect, my point is that China has the upper hand over India.
- kajecounterhack 16y agoAgreed -- honestly this is a topic of constant debate with regards to China and I think most can agree that things have improved significantly in the past decade. Sure 700 million peasants, but it was even more and as China continues its rapid industrialization, more will leave the farms for the cities. In fact that's already happening, so much so that the issue is primarily how to deal with population influx. I mean if you look into American history it's a lot of repetition. Packingtown / chinese sweatshops. It's the same thing over again! Leaving the farm for the industrialized city...yeesh. A choice between "ignorant peasants" or "smart people looking after everyone's interests" is simply irrelevant / nonexistent. The problem right now is developing infrastructure to modernize a country.
- liuliu 16y agoBut the "ignorant peasants" are doing great in China. They are the first one who signed the contract with government to "rent the land" and do the agriculture themselves. They are the main forces of Chinese small businesses (Wenzhou is a great example) and they are the main work forces for outsourcing industry in China. We shouldn't be blind by the elite-leading economy in China these days (the PE etc.). Actually, I am quite worried about these "smart people looking after everyone's interests".