3 ms·
Doesn't seem like necessarily the best qualification to me. Mathematicians do (1) teaching, and (2) mathematical research. Neither of those two is remotely like
by jacobolus 16y ago
Doesn't seem like necessarily the best qualification to me. Mathematicians do (1) teaching, and (2) mathematical research. Neither of those two is remotely like taking a timed test. Of course, in this particular case it’s not clear that the candidate has demonstrated he can do competent mathematical work. I can’t imagine the prof. would be going to the mat here if the student couldn’t handle stressful exams but was otherwise a brilliant mathematician.
- Nitramp 16y agoI agree, in particular with your second point. But the problem is: where do you draw the line? Is it only test anxiety, what about people struck by procrastination that don't manage to finish a thesis? Why is that not a valid medical condition? Is being lazy maybe also a medical condition? And being not all that smart? But more importantly, how do you make sure such excuses are not exploited by people simply failing the standards?
- gregpilling 16y agoThe student did not even complete the coursework. That alone should have prevented the PhD.