8 ms·
This story is much less about actual earnings, instead it's more about perceived future earnings. Apple makes almost twice as much money as Microsoft does, but
by bryanlarsen 8y ago
This story is much less about actual earnings, instead it's more about perceived future earnings.
Apple makes almost twice as much money as Microsoft does, but their valuations are similar. Thus the "market" believes that Microsoft's revenue is going to grow much faster than Apple's will.
As the article says, it appears to be the massive cloud revenue that has investors pumped. But much of that cloud revenue is probably Office 360, so is it really the type of cloud revenue people should be excited about? If it was categorized separately, I doubt investors would be so excited.
I suspect the answer is somewhere in the middle: Office revenue is a fairly mature business without the growth potential that AWS or Azure has, but Office 360 is a pretty powerful tool for Microsoft to use get companies to choose Azure over AWS.
Could Apple pull the same trick? Investors probably implicitly value App Store revenue as more likely to grow than hardware revenue so Apple could probably find ways to shift revenue from hardware to App Store. The next question is how much Apple cares about short term stock market shenanigans versus long term real growth. Apple employees hold a lot of RSU's so stock market shenanigans are well incentivized...
- oblio 8y agoAzure itself is also growing, and Office 365 still has a lot of on-premise installations to pull over. So there's definitely room for Microsoft to grow.
- dmoy 8y agoAnd Azure has an insane amount of headroom to grow in to, if they do well. The market there is potentially huge, on the order of multiple times bigger than all advertising.
- bryanlarsen 8y agoTop line (gross revenue) growth potential is massive. Bottom line (net revenue) growth is much more questionable. If you're just selling CPU cycles, that's a commodity in a market with strong competition keeping prices down. And Google/Kubernetes is working hard to turn the other value adds of AWS/Azure into a commodity as well.
- arethuza 8y agoMicrosoft has a huge portfolio of application with SaaS versions (from SharePoint through to Dynamics 365 CRM and ERPs) - Google doesn't play in those spaces at all.
- bryanlarsen 8y agoBut Microsoft is not competition free in any of those fields. The question then becomes how much of a bundling advantage Microsoft can give itself. Many of these competitors are or should be supporting Kubernetes to pursue a "commoditize the complements" strategy.
- arethuza 8y agoBut the competitors in those fields say Oracle or SAP are minor players elsewhere. Microsoft's pretty open about SaaS > PaaS > IaaS - raw VMs/containers/storage is a commodity business.
- StillBored 8y agoIts apparently quite significant: https://kevinmccauley.com/2016/02/29/60-percent-of-azure-images-are-linux/ https://kevinmccauley.com/2016/02/29/60-percent-of-azure-ima...
- basch 8y ago>If you're just selling CPU cycles That's not the end game. It's to develop services (apis) and sell access to them on a per use basis. Then youre wiring logic between the services. Neither Azure nor AWS nor Google want your code and containers to be portable between infrastructures. They want to offer the hard compute functions to you in rental form.
- bryanlarsen 8y agoGoogle does want your code and containers to be portable between infrastructures. Kubernetes is very strong evidence of this intent. They appear to have decided that being the obvious place for Kubernetes hosting is worth more to them than competing against AWS & Azure in a world without Kubernetes.
- isolli 8y agoI also have to admit I was pretty impressed with their Machine Learning offering: https://youtu.be/hXG_zvpaZF4 https://youtu.be/hXG_zvpaZF4
- tracker1 8y agoOne thing I will say that I appreciate about Azure... is they do have an "easy" option for most of their services, that lets me access them as a client from wherever... so a locally running service can be backed by Azure Storage services initially, or for interaction in early development. The same goes for Azure SQL, etc. Yeah, it's a bit more pricey but the reduction in friction in a business setting is everything.
- raesene9 8y agoPersonally I'd say that Office365 revenue is great revenue, as it's recurring and has good lock-in. MS have wanted to get people onto subscription style licensing for a long time now (since at least the software assurance days) as it's predictable and repeating revenue. The other element is the one you point out, companies that move to Office365 are more likely to choose Azure over AWS as there are synergies (like being able to us Azure AD for both) which make it a good idea. The growth in cloud probably has a way to run as more companies come up to renew products and servers and move them to the cloud. With Apple I guess the forward picture is more tricky. Their main hardware markets are a) getting saturated and b) getting more comptetive For services, I'm not sure they have as great a story. I use iCloud as it works well with my iDevices but I'm not that wedded to it.
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoPersonally I'd say that Office365 revenue is great revenue, as it's recurring and has good lock-in. It is but calling it cloud revenue is a bit of a stretch, I don't know why they are being dishonest about it.
- scirocco 8y agoCIO's love calling Office365 "cloud" and "digital transformation" Right...
- basch 8y agoWhy? It's hosted sharepoint and exchange and lync and active directory, AND development of sharepoint and exchange and lync and active directory. It's not just buying hosting from rackspace. Office 365, OWA, SharePoint Online/OneDrive, AD, and Teams (VoIP) are absolutely a cloud service.
- GVIrish 8y agoExactly. Everyone reads "Office 365" and think that it only means Word/Excel/Powerpoint, when it actually includes Sharepoint and Exchange as well as OneDrive. The cost and support savings for enterprises going from on-prem to cloud with stuff like Sharepoint can be huge. And Microsoft, for all its faults, understands the enterprise market in a way that Google and Apple definitely don't. I think Amazon has a better understanding of enterprise customers but they don't have the product offering to rival what Microsoft brings to the game. And because of the synergies Microsoft can offer, they can eat into the pie of other companies like Salesforce. Dynamics CRM isn't as good as Salesforce but it's easier to justify if you've already bought into the rest of the Office365 ecosystem. I think Microsoft is poised for serious growth with their cloud offerings that is going to drive strong stock price growth for years to come.
- josefresco 8y ago"The next question is how much Apple cares about short term stock market shenanigans versus long term real growth." Isn't that what Microsoft has been doing? Boring "businesses-y" stuff that surprise is growing whereas Apple is selling hyped, shiny objects that might fizzle but hasn't...yet?
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoI'm not sure it's really about how shiny the devices are, rather how much of Apple's revenue is tied up in one product.
- jedberg 8y agoI think you're on point, and I think it bothers Amazon too. During yesterday's re:Invent keynote, the AWS CEO specifically called out that while Microsoft's cloud numbers were growing faster by percentage, their actual dollar growth was insignificant compared to the power of the force -- I mean compared to AWS.
- GVIrish 8y ago> Apple makes almost twice as much money as Microsoft does, but their valuations are similar. Thus the "market" believes that Microsoft's revenue is going to grow much faster than Apple's will. The market for tablets is pretty much saturated, and the market for smartphones is no longer expanding at a breakneck rate. Laptops/desktops are not a growth segment, so Apple doesn't have huge potential for growth anymore unless they can find a new and very profitable product segment. Apple isn't even really trying in any kind of serious way in the enterprise market, and their cloud efforts are only focused on supporting iOS for the most part. So where Microsoft (and Amazon) is poised for strong growth, Apple isn't even on the playing field. I think back when the iPad 1 and 2 was gaining traction and getting businesses excited about tablets, is when Apple should've made a big push into enterprise. I think a lot of orgs (particularly gov't and hospitals) would've changed to being Mac shops if Apple offered the server, productivity, and desktop/device admin tools enterprise needs. But they largely ignored that opportunity and now the window is all but closed. I know Apple's philosophy was to have a laser focus on what they do well, which was consumer hardware and software. But I think they had/have more than enough money to be a strong player in the enterprise market. What could have been.
- pmart123 8y agoI guess is there a reason to believe Apple would be good at providing enterprise IT or infrastructure services, especially when its become hyper-competitive? Delivering to enterprise is usually about customizing 10-20% around edge cases versus delivering one seamless, yet rigid experience.
- GVIrish 8y agoWhen you're sitting on as much cash as Apple, they can find a way. It's just a question of whether they are willing to adapt their habits and philosophy to serve the enterprise market correctly. I think you hit on a key point, which is that enterprise customers need the ability to customize to get to that last 10-20% of use cases. Right now Amazon and Microsoft have a huge lead in the enterprise cloud, but I don't think that lead is insurmountable. Apple would just have to find a unique angle they could exploit. Maybe come up with much cheaper alternatives to some of the Office 365 products and bundle it with open source SaaS/PaaS offerings.
- JamesBarney 8y agoIt's pretty well known that Microsoft folds their office revenue into the cloud so I'd be surprised if it's fooling many investors sophisticated enough to differentiate the revenue.
- pier25 8y ago> Could Apple pull the same trick? I seriously doubt it. I think Apple management doesn't really have a clue how to build a cloud business for developers and the enterprise. Tim Cook for example is no Satya Nadella. He has grown Apple to be very profitable, but clearly has no technological vision like Jobs did.
- MagicPropmaker 8y agoApple never did software well. They failed at writing their own operating system (Pink, Taligent) and had to buy NeXT. Now they're pushing Apollo-era Unix technology to its breaking point, while Microsoft moves ahead.
- ThJ 8y agoThe UNIX heritage of macOS may be from the Apollo era, but so is the UNIX heritage of Linux, an operating system that pretty much powers the infrastructure of the Internet. Using macOS isn't so different from using something like Ubuntu Linux. There's a polished user interface and a UNIX-like system underneath that can be accessed with a terminal emulator. And Windows? Well, the guy who originally designed Windows NT was also involved with the Apollo-era VMS operating system, and incorporated a lot of VMS-like stuff in there. The NT kernel still forms the basis of Windows 10. TL;DR: Don't knock old things just because they're old.
- MagicPropmaker 8y agoThe initial release of VMS was 1977, well after Apollo. And NT's initial release was first release in July 1983, leveraging the hard lessons learned from Unix and VMS.
- ThJ 8y agoLast Apollo mission was in 1972, so only 5 years after. I honestly didn't check the date of the last Apollo mission but I knew it was in the 1970s. Point is, both UNIX and VMS are ancient, and it doesn't matter, which was my entire point...
- mr_toad 8y agoThe thing is that even if Azure took all cloud revenue, and the cloud continued to grow at projected rates it would be several years before the combination of cloud and traditional software exceeded Apple’s current revenue. And realistically, Azure is not going to capture the majority of cloud market share any time soon.
- jonhendry18 8y agoMicrosoft isn't as exposed to tariffs on Chinese imports.