2 ms·
> Nearly all research purporting to date past branches of populations based on mtDNA mutations by assuming a maternal clone is passed, and any differences are
by samatman 8y ago
> Nearly all research purporting to date past branches of populations based on mtDNA mutations by assuming a maternal clone is passed, and any differences are mutations, is completely off. All that research is and always has been invalid.
This is a drastic and totally implausible statement that is not supported by any serious geneticist, nor by the Wikipedia article you've linked to.
mtDNA does not have to come exclusively, 100%, no-exceptions-ever from the mother, in order for population research which uses to be valid! 99% is quite sufficient. It is at least 99.9% accurate: as the Wikipedia article helpfully points out, there are 1000x as many mitochondria in an egg as in a sperm.
- droithomme 8y agoYou're attacking a strawman. mtDNA can be used to track lineages. It's the dating of when branches occurred that is off because it assumes all differences are due to mutations and not paternal contributions.
- whatshisface 8y agoThat's a good insight - it's not whether or not the rate of paternal inheritance is high, it's whether or not the rate of paternal inheritance is high relative to the rate of mutation. What are those rates for mDNA?
- samatman 8y agoI am not. The rate of mutation is already not a constant, and so such dating is always approximate, there is a margin of error. If you wish to demonstrate that it is now "completely off" and "invalid", try harder. I call shenanigans.
- gus_massa 8y agoI'd have to take a look at the details, but I'm 99% sure that the important part is that the mitochondrial DNA has no crossover, so all the differences are due to mutations and it is a real tree. With normal DNA the crossover add some changes and in particular it mix the changes in one branch of the tree with the changes in the other branch of the tree, so it's not longer a tree. So my guess is that it will not change the dates too much, specially since he dates are calibrated by historical events. With made up numbers, something like "we know that this population reach here 10000 years ago and has 37 changes and that population reach there 20000 years ago and has 69 changes. This other population has 53 changes so after some complicated math, we estimate that they split 15000-1600 years ago. I guess that the size of the population at the bottlenecks will be slightly reduced, because IIUC they are not calibrated using historical data but using some mathematical models about how the size of the population affect the diversity. I don't expect a big change nevertheless.
- rossdavidh 8y agoIt seems also plausible that the cases where paternal mtDNA are passed on, would be disproportionately likely to have mitochondrial disease and thus eventually die out. We don't know that this is so, but it seems more likely true than not, given what we do know. If so, they would not really impact research done over evolutionary timescales.