3 ms·

I’ve found that the best professors tend to come with higher standards for grading, more involved assignments, and just generally more work involved. This is gr

by setr 8y ago

I’ve found that the best professors tend to come with higher standards for grading, more involved assignments, and just generally more work involved. This is great if you’re actively interested in learning the subject; most students are not. In which case, its far worse than the shitty teacher, and its reflected in the feedback. From the perspective of most students, the ideal professor has low grading standards, “good enough” teaching, and most importantly, a “fun” class (primarily by means of humor). Most students are there to get a degree, to get a job. The best teacher according to students is the one that best fits that model (which is generally at odds with the goals of classical academia).

tmin 8y ago
One of the best classes that I had was very hard in homeworks but was easy on the grading. It was literature and art class taught by a lawyer. I felt that I grew up a bit after that class. The class was also rated high by students
- setr 8y ago
  I was thinking primarily of my history with stem (really, specifically the t and e); I feel like the arts are still more classically oriented, because a degree isn’t anywhere near as required, and theres weaker guarantees on income streams, such that its been relatively unaffected by the university trying to fulfill the role if trade schools. The same would be true of mathematics, phds in general, and probably most of the hard sciences. Undergrad feedback I wouldn’t trust at all regardless of major, Masters is major-dependent (ce, cs are particularly screwed) and phd candidates are probably fine. Simply by looking at the why the general population is even in the major (eg ask an undergrad and the reason is probably not actual interest in the subject: parents, jobs, money, dropout-major, couldn’t decide, best grades in hs, etc). Their feedback will naturally reflect the misaligned incentives If your interest in feedback is to make sure the teachers are actually good at teaching, anyways.

by setr 8y ago

tmin 8y ago

One of the best classes that I had was very hard in homeworks but was easy on the grading. It was literature and art class taught by a lawyer. I felt that I grew up a bit after that class. The class was also rated high by students

setr 8y ago
I was thinking primarily of my history with stem (really, specifically the t and e); I feel like the arts are still more classically oriented, because a degree isn’t anywhere near as required, and theres weaker guarantees on income streams, such that its been relatively unaffected by the university trying to fulfill the role if trade schools. The same would be true of mathematics, phds in general, and probably most of the hard sciences. Undergrad feedback I wouldn’t trust at all regardless of major, Masters is major-dependent (ce, cs are particularly screwed) and phd candidates are probably fine. Simply by looking at the why the general population is even in the major (eg ask an undergrad and the reason is probably not actual interest in the subject: parents, jobs, money, dropout-major, couldn’t decide, best grades in hs, etc). Their feedback will naturally reflect the misaligned incentives If your interest in feedback is to make sure the teachers are actually good at teaching, anyways.