3 ms·
This feels too much like an appeal to wishful thinking. I can't say that you are wrong. But this doesn't exactly fill me with confidence. Probably doesn't he
by taeric 8y ago
This feels too much like an appeal to wishful thinking.
I can't say that you are wrong. But this doesn't exactly fill me with confidence. Probably doesn't help that I don't really have a minds eye. I am probably clinging too heavily for some "underlying truth", as well.
Reminds me of the complaints I'll see, where folks bemoan that nobody learns the reason math works anymore. Only, that doesn't really make sense. Few of us ever really learned "why math works" because it turns out that is not nearly as straight forward as folks assert that it is.
- SubiculumCode 8y agoWell, I did refer to it as an analogy. However, I do think there are probably several useful analogies between machine learning and neuroscience. For example: Sparse Encoding http://www.mit.edu/~9.54/fall14/Classes/class07/Palm.pdf http://www.mit.edu/~9.54/fall14/Classes/class07/Palm.pdf
- taeric 8y agoOh, it is definitely an analogy. I should have stressed more that I don't think you are wrong. Not just that I can't say you are wrong. I really don't think you are. My concern is that I'm just not sure how far that analogy helps. Unlike old analytic models, we don't have much in the way of analyzing these new models. We can only talk towards how well they perform on fixed data sets. There are some interesting results in transfer learning. But, I suspect most of the truly amazing results have been essentially cherry picked in the process. (That is, blind pigs and troughs, and all of that. I hope I'm wrong. I really do.