3 ms·
To be clear - I wasn't saying manned multirotors are an impossible dream. I'd love to someday build one myself. They're not practical transportation (yet!) thou
by taneq 8y ago
To be clear - I wasn't saying manned multirotors are an impossible dream. I'd love to someday build one myself. They're not practical transportation (yet!) though, for a bunch of reasons:
- Carrying capacity is very limited. The best current tech is at its limit getting one human off the ground for a few minutes, doing better will need magic batteries from the future
- Multirotors using fixed pitch rotors need to vary the rotor speed rapidly to control the thrust and torque of the rotors, and you can't do that fast with big rotors (the rotors on this thing are already too big to control efficiently like this)
- Variable pitch rotors add too much weight and complexity, if you're going variable pitch you might as well just build a helicopter (and if this thing's using variable pitch it still doesn't have enough rotors to survive a single failure unless it has well over 2:1 max lift to weight ratio so you've gone from one critical point of failure on a helicopter to 4+ just on the rotors for this thing)
- Rotorcraft efficiency (lift per kW of power) is determined by disc loading, which means you need a ton of small rotors for a useful amount of lift with non-bonkers power usage (this thing's dual coaxial rotors are way too small to be efficient)
- A rotorcraft with a ton of small rotors (https://www.volocopter.com/en/product/ https://www.volocopter.com/en/product/ say) is going to have a ton of complexity and a high failure rate, this is actually an advantage of multirotors since (with enough rotors and enough spare power) they can tolerate single failures so you won't crash but your rotorcraft is still going to need fixing regularly
Helicopters aren't as expensive as they are because the airframe is expensive (it's just fibreglass usually) or even because the powertrain is expensive (it is though). They're expensive because they're regulated to hell and back by the FAA or your local equivalent and require exhaustive certifications, maintenance etc. You could build a helicopter for $10k in your back shed but good luck getting permission to fly it at all, much less as a taxi service, MUCH less over people's houses.
(All this is just my understanding, I'm not an aeronautical engineer, just someone who loves rotorcraft. :P )