3 ms·
Derek Lowe has a nice summary of the situation and why it's sloppy science.[1] Multiple microinjections were needed to try to ensure that the majority of cells
by refurb 8y ago
Derek Lowe has a nice summary of the situation and why it's sloppy science.[1]
Multiple microinjections were needed to try to ensure that the majority of cells in the embryo were indeed affected, He said, and even so neither of the twin girls appears to be a clean job of it. One of them is mosaic for the desired 32-amino acid CCR5 deletion, and the other, if I’m reading this right, is heterozygous for a five amino acid deletion. Wonderful, a complete hack job.
[1]http://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2018/11/28/after-such-knowledge http://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2018/11/28/aft...
- buboard 8y agoCurious why this wasn't asked during his talk. Aren't +/- knockouts valid knockouts ?
- buboard 8y agofrom reddit's biologists i got this: > he actually doesn't report a mosaic at the CCR5delta32 locus - just a mosaic off-target effect in a non-coding region that disappears when sequencing tissues from the baby and heterozygous knockouts are still knockouts so i m not sure why they are so quick to discredit the work