6 ms·
My dad used to work in local government and likes to call the automatic opposition, "People united against anything." Today we call them NIMBYs. California has
by jseliger 8y ago
My dad used to work in local government and likes to call the automatic opposition, "People united against anything." Today we call them NIMBYs. California has empowered them in peculiar and powerful ways, as anyone, anywhere, can challenge any project under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), which actually supersedes the national version (NEQA).
- wyldfire 8y agoAnd yet development should take the environment into consideration because it can have massive consequences. Those consequences are ultimately an externality of the development project and evaluating it in advance can help inform the true financials of the project.
- dpcx 8y agoI wonder whether those that were taking the environment in to consideration for the development thought beyond the project to what environmental impacts could be lessened by the project. I'm not a Musk fanboy, but if these tunnels will work the way he's suggesting, the amount of traffic that would be removed from the roads (and by extension, the pollution) would probably be a net benefit to the environment.
- freeflight 8y ago> traffic that would be removed from the roads (and by extension, the pollution) I don't understand how any pollution would be removed, just because it's now in tunnels doesn't equal it being gone. Wouldn't it just be blasted back out through the ventilation system? Or were there plans to build some kind of "pollution scrubbing" into those?
- deegles 8y agoI think the tunnels would run electric cars/trains only.
- Symmetry 8y agoAlso, cars use a minimum of CO2/mile when traveling at 40mph. Time spent idling in traffic is time spent burning gas to no purpose and to the extent that these tunnels decrease surface traffic there are add on benefits.
- enraged_camel 8y agoOkay, but what about the (probably massive) upfront environmental costs of digging the tunnels and building their infrastructure?
- cujo 8y agoI would question if it would actually lower traffic, or just allow more people to travel.
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>or just allow more people to travel. Which is an increase in quality of life for those who would have otherwise forgone those trips. Either way it's a win. Whether it's a big enough win to be worth the cost is a perpetual debate with projects like this.
- anonymou2 8y agoAn increase in quality of life? Really? Who is to tell? Maybe those people would have done something more fulfilling instead of whatever they did as the porpose of those trips.
- njarboe 8y ago"Who is to tell?" Generally the person themselves should be the one to tell. Other systems have not worked out so well.
- mattigames 8y agoThe biggest win -if it works as expected- would be the influence on other cities to do similar projects and focus on creating fast-and-electric-powered alternatives to move cars; also there may be a gain in safety issues due not relying in the driving skills of its users.
- Anechoic 8y agoWhich is the point of an environmental assessment: to look at the benefits and cost to the environment and document the net result. This isn’t about declaring the project a hazard to the environment, this is skipping the process to determine if it is or isn’t a net good.
- zebrafish 8y agoWho foots the bill for such an assessment?
- HillaryBriss 8y ago> the amount of traffic that would be removed from the roads seriously, how would that work? any expansion of road capacity in LA is immediately used up and oversaturated. if you build it they will come. if you free roads up by providing an alternative like Musk's tunnel system, someone else will still come and fill the roads back up, because, "hey, traffic is moving again."
- drb91 8y agoCars fill the capacity of the roads. LA will just get more cars. LA deserves better public transit.
- mayamatrix 8y agoWhere do you think the pollution from all those added cars is going to go?
- chrisco255 8y agoAll states have some form of this, but CA takes it to another level.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pj_mukh 8y agoOddly enough, currently the opposite is true. All the construction blocks being put up sometimes in the name of environmental assessment are pushing people out of dense areas and into sprawling suburbs, with people taking on huge commutes to get to work. Where is the environmental assessment on NIMBY-ism I wonder? :/
- wyldfire 8y agoI've read articles that talk about that debate. Indeed, I tend to agree that development to support denser population is often an environmental net win over the immediate local environmental impacts, but I suppose it should be case-by-case.
- gamblor956 8y agoThere is a lot of construction going on in LA right now. It's actually quite easy to get new construction approved if you just follow the rules. Of course, if you choose not to follow the rules and processes for development...it's very difficult. Elon's learning the hard way that not following the rules can make his pet projects difficult or even impossible.
- lsmarigo 8y ago"California has empowered them in peculiar and powerful ways" Fun example of this is John Wayne airport in Orange County pilots do a special takooff involving cutting power to engines to reduce noise for Newport Beach neighborhood below dating back to a lawsuit from the 80s.
- et2o 8y agoThis seems reasonable to me. If they can take off while reducing nose pollution, they should. I wonder if they do this at other airports located in of near cities such as LGA.
- mikeash 8y agoIt's a pretty common thing. Here's a long survey and discussion of various noise abatement procedures that I haven't actually read through: https://www.icao.int/environmental-protection/Documents/ReviewNADRD.pdf https://www.icao.int/environmental-protection/Documents/Revi... I have some mildly related personal experience as well. The glider club I belong to started getting noise complaints from people living near the airport. On a busy day, our tow plane might make 25 takeoffs. We often took the same path every time, repeatedly annoying the same people. We started varying our routes and also replaced the propellor with a quieter one and everybody was happy.
- mips_avatar 8y agoGlad you guys worked it out.
- lsmarigo 8y agoSeems unreasonable to me, who's to say which neighborhood deserves more or less noise pollution? Oh right, economic status and ability to file massive lawsuits. If that takeoff method was all around better they would just do it everywhere, Congress outlawed other airports from doing the same in 1990 "In 1990, Congress, fearing that many localities could eventually hamstring the growth of aviation by implementing their own patchwork of noise restrictions, passed the Airport Noise and Capacity Act which outlawed curfews at airports. John Wayne was grandfathered in, however, due to the original lawsuit being filed in 1985." https://www.avgeekery.com/whats-rollercoaster-takeoffs-orange-county/ https://www.avgeekery.com/whats-rollercoaster-takeoffs-orang...
- simias 8y agoIt's our profound nature as humans to reflexively unite against any outside change we don't feel part of. It's true at every scale and level of society. From "they don't make good music these days" to racism to opposition to political reforms. It's frankly a huge problem for humanity as a whole. We don't like change, especially if it's forced upon us. With climate change looming in the distance it's an almost suicidal trait. On the other hand not letting anybody do what they want when they feel like it is important if you want to maintain a working society so it's a very tricky balance to maintain. It's probably reasonable for Californian residents not to let anybody dig holes willy-nilly underneath their cities. That being said the article is pretty thin on details. They mention "a review of its potential environment impact" but don't explain what the problem was exactly, so it's hard for me to form an educated opinion on this particular case.
- jimmy1 8y agoCall me crazy, but as an outsider looking in with attachment to California (many friends moved from there, brother's wife from there, I visit often), isn't part of their empowerment of NIMBY's out of fear that if they don't empower them they will straight up leave? Owning a home in California close to any of the economic centers sounds like one of the hardest endeavors one could embark upon, I imagine if you don't give any sort of concessions then more people would straight up leave.
- mikeash 8y agoCalifornia's insane housing prices (at least near the aforementioned economic centers) indicates that people are clamoring to move there. If you drive people away, more will replace them, possibly after causing prices to drop somewhat.
- jimmy1 8y agoTo me it indicates much more than that: high taxes, high regulatory fees, high cost of labor. The median cost per square foot for a home in California is $319 dollars, the median cost per square foot for the entire U.S is $151. The median home price in California is $379,000, and the U.S. is $225,000. One only needs to do a simple web search to see the current migration from California's tech centers to other tech destinations such as Austin, for example (note in my previous comment I said more people will leave, people are already leaving) >If you drive people away, more will replace them There is no data to support this hypothesis, however, in this case. The facts are California housing is expensive, and there are not enough jobs at those wages to support the expensive houses.
- mikeash 8y agoPrices can't exist without people willing to pay them. It doesn't matter how high your taxes, fees, and labor costs are, if people aren't willing to pay, prices don't stay high. Another way of interpreting "The median home price is California is $379,000" is "people are willing to pay, on average, $379,000 for a home in California." The home prices are the data to support my hypothesis. If there wasn't demand for houses then prices would fall. Demand for houses means people want to move there. If there were a net migration out of the state, prices would be dropping.
- V-2 8y ago> My dad used to work in local government and likes to call the automatic opposition, "People united against anything." Today we call them NIMBYs. I love the BANANA acronym, which stands for "build absolutely nothing anywhere near anything".
- simonebrunozzi 8y agoNever heard of it before, but it's absolutely brilliant.
- sjg007 8y agoEventually Elon will give up and take a helicopter to work.
- xkjkls 8y agoHe already takes a Gulfstream
- drb91 8y agoI associate NIMBYs with going against things that improve a neighborhood. I don’t think that includes all types of resistance.
- xkjkls 8y agoThe problem is NIMBYs think that no things improve the neighborhood. Everyone would say they are for things that improve the neighborhood, but some are reflexively anti-change.
- drb91 8y agoWell, that may be true, but there is good reason to doubt the effects of adding more roads to LA: demand will grow to meet capacity, which I am sure Musk is aware of given that he runs a car company.