4 ms·
Huawei: NZ bars Chinese firm on national security fears
- cbzbc 8y agoThe UK government started worrying about the same thing when Huawei won a bunch of BT 21CN contracts for network renewal. The chosen solution in that case was to set up a dedicated engineering facility onshore, where evaluation of the products could be performed at various levels before deployment. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/huawei-cyber-security-evaluation-centre-oversight-board-annual-report-2017 https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/huawei-cyber-secu...
- ardy42 8y ago> The chosen solution in that case was to set up a dedicated engineering facility onshore, where evaluation of the products could be performed at various levels before deployment. Honestly, that doesn't seem like a good plan. While such a lab is better than nothing, it doesn't protect the UK against attacks it didn't understand or think to look for. I'm reminded of this Soviet bug that was given to the American embassy in Moscow and lay undetected for seven years. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Thing_(listening_device) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Thing_(listening_device) The fact that the lab was created for Huawei tells me they're not trusted enough. The smart thing to do is to pick vendors you already trust not to bug you, and then do the extensive verification as an additional check.
- cbzbc 8y agoMy description of what they did was not meant as an endorsement. That said; in an age where a large percentage of physical devices/device parts are made in China - protecting against attacks you don't understand or think to look for is a non trivial exercise and can't be avoided merely by changing vendor (though doing so may make an attack harder).
- Lio 8y agoI think that's actually part of the problem. The choice by BT to go with Huawei for 21CN effectively killed off home grown Marconi products. BT saved a bit of money short term and Ben Verwaayen got his bonus but long term they are now dependant on products they can't really control where before they could pop down the road to Chelmsford and go and speak to the design team.
- paraditedc 8y agonvm (comment removed)
- ahmedalsudani 8y agoHuawei is selling telecommunications infrastructure. There's a big (and clear) difference between that and ecommerce sites.
- nolok 8y agoThere is a very big difference between blocking the public (both consumers and business) from dealing with companies from someplace, and blocking companies from that place from getting access to critical infrastructure. Especially if said company is controlled by its government. Especially if said company has been caught using said kind of access to spy for its owner government before. Especially if said country has made a reputation of systematically stealing all the tech and spying any way it could on you to use it "against" you. Especially if said country is not part of the same geopolitical block as you. Especially if said government does the same thing to your own companies in the same field. Confusing regular commercial dealing and critical infrastructure deal and acting like they have the same security need or that one leads to another makes no sense to me, so your comment is, in my opinion, out of line.
- paraditedc 8y agoMaybe TikTok is a better example, given its ability to influence public opinions.
- mtw 8y agoI would love to see a page demonstrating specific vulnerabilities or data theft by Huawei. So far, in comments, it's always "oh they must be doing it", "Oh I've heard about them doing X and Y" or other similar unsubstantiated claims
- aDfbrtVt 8y agoTheir current long-haul optical portfolio exist because they stole the IP from Nortel (as in bugged the building and stole the source code).
- mtrovo 8y agoI think the public reason to ban them is totally fine but there’s a lot of more stuff in play here. Think about the presence of Android in China, they worry about Android phones having Play services calling home with more data than it’s needed to work properly. This is not theory, it was shown in the past and we never know how much data we’re sending back to Google or even Facebook just by owning an Android device. So they block Google Play services, in the name of its citizens right to privacy or whatever. Now the same due diligence is not taken into account for the same kind of services provided by local companies. They can operate without a lot of backslash over data collection or backdoors. But for them (Chinese government) this is still a better alternative. Because the data is not siting on a data center in US waiting to be mined by some agency that happen to have three letters and no need for a mandate to look at data from non citizens. So the reason to ban them is right, but it’s not just banning them to spy on us. This is also saying that if somebody is going to spy on our communications it better be on our side of the fence. Maybe Cisco could win without a lot of fuss about “possible threats that we don’t understand right now”. Maybe Cisco also have code with dubious quality, or even straight malicious, but at least the data exfiltration is not sitting on a data center in China.
- guitarbill 8y agoIs it though? A much simpler explaination is that China - like any nation - can compel it's citizens quite easily to do something (carrot or stick). And tapping into/backdooring infrastructure a very effective approach. How do the Five Eyes governments know this? Because they were doing the exact same thing, with help from e.g. telcos. But most foreign telcos are somewhat well monitored, so attacking the hardware is the next logical step. There's no mystery here, it's just they can't come right out and say "this is how we would have done it", because they probably did.