4 ms·
It's not just about pleasing the audience. Showing respect and appreciation for the game itself is important to chess players, and to competitive sports overall
by Barrin92 8y ago
It's not just about pleasing the audience. Showing respect and appreciation for the game itself is important to chess players, and to competitive sports overall.
People who follow and participate in competitions passionately don't usually just try to maximize their chances to win, they also want to deliver the best effort they can.
Magnus Carlsen specifically was always respected for his fighting spirit. In his championship game against Anand a few years ago he played out a practically drawn endgame to a win through sheer tenacity, and he once managed to win a game in St Louis where a draw that was offered to him would have won him the tournament on the spot, but he declined and played it out.
This fighting aspect has always made him an especially great player (not just for the game and the audience, but it has also put him above the competition).
- mlthoughts2018 8y agoThis reply borders on incoherent to me. What is best effort if not choosing the course of action you deem gives you the best chance to win? Exhausting yourself and risking a blunder in the final classical match just because other people want to see the spectacle of it? That doesn’t seem like “effort” at all. Why do soccer players make back passes from offensive positions when tied 0-0? You think the coach gives a shit at that point if the crowd wants someone to give “effort” in a press, leaving exposed chances for a sudden counter-attack? Sometimes playing the back pass is the right “best effort” to be made. Same with an intentional kneel to run out the clock before halftime instead of risking injury or a turnover on a last second play in American football. Or intentionally walking a home run hitter in baseball if you think you stand a great chance to strike out the next batter. You seem to be conflating “best effort” with “intentionally disregard the strategy you deem best because a riskier course of action would be more appreciated by spectators.”
- BurningFrog 8y agoYes, OP is talking about being respected by the chess world, not merely winning the title.
- mlthoughts2018 8y agoExactly, the OP is mistakenly conflating “respected by the chess world” (which is not equal to the prevailing opinion of casual fans) with some confused idea of taking unnecessary risks that jeopardize a sound strategy.
- mlthoughts2018 8y agoBoy, after today’s results, whoever was defending the idea that Magnus should have abandoned his match strategy to play out a minor advantage in Game 12 must be feeling pretty embarrassed over such a ridiculous point of view.
- nabla9 8y agoWhen trying to win does not produce beautiful games, then the game itself is faulty. They should change the rules of the games. Like time auction suggested where draw is win for black pieces.