4 ms·
The problems are (1) that they get a special definition of "negligent" and "force" than the rest of us, and (2) that they and prosecutors cover up malfeasance (
by loeg 8y ago
The problems are (1) that they get a special definition of "negligent" and "force" than the rest of us, and (2) that they and prosecutors cover up malfeasance (the blue line); not that the stakes aren't high enough if they are found guilty.
Raising the stakes for a group that already protects its own just increases its incentive to cover up malfeasance.
- pstuart 8y agoI recognize that my suggestion is easier said than done, but the coverup mentality seems to be a full effect anyway so it would be shame to not explore this for that worry alone.
- naasking 8y ago> (2) that they and prosecutors cover up malfeasance (the blue line); What's needed is something more systemic: abolish prosecutorial discretion. Prosecutors will then have no choice but to pursue these cases or face prosecution themselves. It also creates incentives to repeal old or broken laws that are used only as leverage against otherwise law abiding citizens. It's a dramatic change, no doubt, but there's a lot to be said for it.
- stevew20 8y agoI completely agree. As for old laws used as leverage... Look up the laws for "gravity knives" in New York. If you live in New York, and carry a pocket knife, you are likely a criminal without knowing it. And it'll likely never become an issue, unless a cop decides that he/she doesn't like you.
- loeg 8y agoWe simply don't have the prosecutors to litigate every case of lawbreaking; there's a reason discretion exists, and it's not to be nice. And dramatic changes don't happen overnight. We start with the system we've got and try to work towards something more fair in little steps.
- naasking 8y ago> We simply don't have the prosecutors to litigate every case of lawbreaking Exactly, and that's part of the problem isn't it? You can address this either by hiring more litigators, or reduce illegality to what's truly essential. The point I'm trying to make is that eliminating prosecutorial discretion creates a different set of incentives whereby the law must be understandable by mere mortals, and eliminates incentives for abuse (the blue line).
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoRe (2): I think those are separate issues. You can only cover up so much. The departments need to start seeing the bad cops as a ticking monetary time bomb. Eventually if you abuse enough people someone will get it on camera and that becomes a slam dunk lawsuit. Re (1): This is a big problem. We need to get rid of the double standard. Whatever rules for use of force the police are playing by they should be at least as restrictive as the rules of engagement that 18yo marines in Afghanistan have to play by. A bad shoot by Joe Average should be a bad shoot when Officer Hotdead does it.
- stevew20 8y agoFantastic example. I've had more than a couple of my Marines end up in hot water for accidentally violating ROEs, and they paid for it. On foreign soil, against a country we were at war with. Shouldn't the same actions back at home be seen as more egregious, not less?
- loeg 8y agoRe: separate issues, that's why I numbered them (1) and (2). I totally agree that increasing transparency in the form of body cameras that can't be disabled really helps make it harder to cover up police abuse. I'm not sure I agree that cops shouldn't get a double standard vs regular citizens — they spend far more time in dangerous / escalating situations than your average hothead with a gun. If they had no double standard protections, it'd be impossible to hire cops (or the ones you'd find would be too stupid to do the job) due to the legal jeopardy. I agree that military discipline makes police look like sloppy amateurs, but the military has the advantage of military training and discipline. Cops by and large don't have that continuing discipline, even those who are former military.