3 ms·
The blind vetting process removes it in the conditional. In that: conditional on having requisite experience and education, you pass a bar. It does nothing to
by tomrod 8y ago
The blind vetting process removes it in the conditional. In that: conditional on having requisite experience and education, you pass a bar.
It does nothing to the joint distribution, in that the conditional distribution ignores that systemic bias has already been applied, this full independence at that point perpetuates the accumulated, extant bias.
- manigandham 8y agoAs first stated, it's not about solving the entirety of your life but about removing that obstacle in that certain situation. You mention an iterative process and yet are seemingly against even the 1st step. Bias is not a one-time thing. It's not just applied and then you live with it forever. Life is a constant stream of dynamic decisions and improving opportunity in one scenario is a positive step forward to improving it elsewhere, and perhaps even countering any earlier biased treatments.
- tomrod 8y agoSo, "social correction" items mentioned earlier could include autarky, where no change gets implemented. This is the system you've argued for across multiple comments. If society agrees, why not. I am for a bit of redistribution, myself, but the positive claim made about perpetuation of bias is simply a systemic fact. Blinding means that, conditional on prior experience and work, your likelihood of landing the job should be constant. That means prior bias gets perpetuated (is built into the factors that generate prior experience and work).
- manigandham 8y agoI never said "autarky" and I'm not sure where you came to that interpretation across comments. I'm for making hiring practices blind, and making similar progress for equality of opportunity across society.
- tomrod 8y agoAutarky in this is referring to using the blind hiring practices with the "intergenerational correction" policy of do nothing else.