6 ms·
Economist here. This will bake in bias that affirmative action and other programs seek to counter. Inequality of opportunity unfortunately isn't countered by th
by tomrod 8y ago
Economist here. This will bake in bias that affirmative action and other programs seek to counter. Inequality of opportunity unfortunately isn't countered by this approach. Why? The same group(s) facing discrimination at the employment point also face discrimination earlier in life, or have baked in social discrimination (such as the US justice system overpenalizing blacks relative to whites/Asians, or Ivy League admission rates for Asians versus other groups).
It would be nice to build a group-blind world, and the more we adopt these specific approaches the better can can iterate towards. However, care should be taken to ensure the baked in biases don't further entrench.
- Aqua 8y agoI'm sorry, but this sounds absurd. Correct me if I'm wrong, but what you're saying implies that employers should hire people that are less qualified for a job just because they belong to a group, members of which on average are more likely to be discriminated earlier in their lives than others? Engineer here, and no, blind hiring will not bake-in any biases, because that's exactly the problem this approach solves - it aims to hire the best candidates regardless of their race, origin, religion, accent and other irrelevant characteristics.
- tomrod 8y agoMy first paragraph I tried very carefully to avoid normative/"should" statements. The identification of the issue is at hand. Consider Computer Science. Historically far fewer women go through the training for a variety of personal reasons and societal pressure. So, on the margin, blind/anonymous hiring ignores that upstream delta between females in population and skilled females in hiring pool. Whether this is desirable or not is not my point, only that this is "baked in bias" perpetuating down the line. It's noble to build a society where we value blindness on characteristics irrelevant to hiring. Doing it piecemeal can result in furthering these baked in biases. A better approach would be to split the skills validation (blind) from the move-forward decision (adhering to whatever inter-generational correction schema the society has decided upon) where the only pool of eligible move-forwards meet the established skills validation. In this way, you only get skilled candidates, and you can satisfy whatever other characteristics that need satisfaction.
- fizwhiz 8y agoWe should all heavily invest in the pipeline problem through outreach and what not, but I'm genuinely curious: what happens if the underrepresented minorities don't make it past the blind skill validation?
- tomrod 8y agoThat's a great question, and one I don't have a great and proper solution for. My splitting suggestion above I consider better than blind-only, but it certainly is not bullet-proof.
- fizwhiz 8y agoI ask because Github attempted this while organizing ElectronConf a year ago, but it turned out their blind submission review process[1] resulted in an all-male panel. Someone noticed and got upset[2], after which Github canned it. There was an HN discussion about it too[3]. Now we can speculate how many submissions were from people that don't identify as male (was it 50 or less%? Github hasn't released details to my knowledge). The issue though is that once the results (of what appears to be a fair process) didn't match the desired narrative, people screamed sexism and made mostly emotional arguments. You've mentioned an "inter-generational correction schema" elsewhere in the thread. In most institutions, this essentially gets instated as quotas which embitters the majority in the system (including the people they target to enable because it's assumed they had to get past a "lower bar"). [1] https://archive.is/8SsNp#selection-381.122-494.0 https://archive.is/8SsNp#selection-381.122-494.0 [2] http://archive.is/NrLqE http://archive.is/NrLqE [3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14480868 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14480868
- tomrod 8y agoIndeed, and I agree. I've tried to be careful from assuming specific norms, trying to think through the positive/observational aspects instead. Applying the selection quota to the hiring pool that passes skills would get around the "quota-implies-less-skilled" issue.
- ianleeclark 8y ago> Engineer here, and no, blind hiring will not bake-in any biases Yes, it will: if you're born to a well-off family, you'll go to better schools before college. Due to this, you'll have a better chance at succeeding in college, have more resources to delve deeper into your field of study, better manage studying abroad, &c. All of these factors will make your list of skills more attractive to employers. Compared to someone who was poor who went to worse schools, didn't study abroad, and couldn't afford to spend more time on their field of study due to having to work to pay for college. This will make your list of skills less attractive to an employer. Right out of the gate, there is a bias against people who grew up poor in the hiring process. > it aims to hire the best candidates regardless of their race, origin, religion, accent and other irrelevant characteristics. It does so by devaluing repressed classes of people. This is a societal cost to benefit businesses.
- klohto 8y agoThe example you showed is absolutely wrong. Based on it, the one from high class has more skills and more experience than the one from lower class. So of course, you will hire the one with more skills. That has nothing to do with class but with the general expertise of an individual. EDIT: I have missed the whole point of the parent comment.
- ianleeclark 8y ago> That has nothing to do with class but with the general expertise of an individual. That expertise is a direct result of class. I feel like I've sufficiently explained how class-based biases will still slip through this system, so respond to it directly and tell me _how bias is not present_ in that system. > Based on it, the one from high class has more skills and more experience than the one from lower class. So of course, you will hire the one with more skills. I never said businesses ought do x, I just said that certain classes will be biased against in this attempt at a bias-less recruitment process which will produce negative outcomes for society.
- klohto 8y ago
- WhompingWindows 8y agoYeah, I don't get that approach either. Is the parent comment suggesting that employers need to assess the opportunities given to a particular applicant and then weight them accordingly? Like if they come from a poor/disadvantaged background and still have 90% the skills and experience of another candidate, well that's more impressive? How does the parent expect an interviewer to come up with these valuations of opportunity?
- Fomite 8y ago"Like if they come from a poor/disadvantaged background and still have 90% the skills and experience of another candidate, well that's more impressive" - Potentially, yes.
- wehere1111 8y agothe point is that current measures of 'best' skew heavily towards certain race, origin, and background
- Aqua 8y agoImplementing a counter-bias will not solve the problem but introduce artificial noise which will obscure data and hide the real issues.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- randyrand 8y agoThe idea for Helsinki is to stop discriminating, not to solve inequality.
- tomrod 8y agoCorrect. However, the problem is the existing discrimination is not remedied, and is instead perpetuated, under a fully blind approach. Inequality is another discussion than bias and discrimination, in my view. Inequality is solved by implementing encouraging measures. Discrimination is resolved by removing entrenched barriers.
- manigandham 8y agoExplain how inequality of opportunity is not countered by this approach? Of course people are a sum of everything that happened in their life, but this is a way to make a particular job application much more fair, based on capability to do the job rather than irrelevant physical details. This is not meant to solve everything at once. The very examples you post are about situations that would be helped if there was blind judgement.
- __Joker 8y agoI don't get it. Yes, it would be much better if we are able to remove discrimination earlier in life. But this is not a either/or solution between affirmative action and equal opportunity. But if the assumption that positive reinforcement make a better just society for future generation then doesn't it mean equal opportunity will make also have the same positive effect albeit a little less ?
- fhbdukfrh 8y agoI think what the GP is stating is that if we only assess accomplishments and we do it at this stage (later in life after many different phases) those systematically disadvantaged will not be competitive (example: If you went to a crummy public school you have a harder time getting into an ivy league, harder time getting a prestige internship, getting a premium job, etc) Affirmative action laws were introduced to address this, but the trend toward meritocracy counters them. My guess; we end up with the worst of both worlds: One stream blind to these factors and a bunch of regulated exceptions.
- tomrod 8y agoGP here. You nailed it.
- chaostheory 8y agoAren't you just pointing out the symptom instead of the real problem we need to be tackling? > The same group(s) facing discrimination at the employment point also face discrimination earlier in life
- tomrod 8y agoIt is being pointed out, but it's not solely pointing out the symptom. The goal of Helsinki here is to make the hiring decision independent of direct factors they blind themselves to (name, sex, etc.). However, the factors they condition on (education, experience) are impacted by these factors, so the hiring decision won't be independent of the factors. The "best" thing to do is to correct the inherent bias, as you're pointing out as the real problem. We agree. This isn't something Helsinki can do in a vacuum, so if they want to achieve their goal of true "blindness" to the above factors, they have to take into account their impact on their "seen" factors somehow. I put the formalized model I have in mind in another comment on this thread, which walks through my thought process here.[0] [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18548270 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18548270