8 ms·
I guess it's eventually distributed but but still centralized in terms of using ipfs and having to go through gateways. A truly distributed means of hosting is
by superkuh 8y ago
I guess it's eventually distributed but but still centralized in terms of using ipfs and having to go through gateways.
A truly distributed means of hosting is everyone hosting their own websites from their home connections. It's simpler and no central authorities are needed. Home connections are plenty fast these days. And the best part is that you get tons of storage space and you don't have to 'upload' anywhere.
You can also make real websites instead of 'single page application' javascript monsters.
- Santosh83 8y agoIn this case you're still beholden to your ISP and whoever controls them. True decentralisation would be something like mesh networks, making use of only local device capabilities.
- superkuh 8y agoIf your ISP is not a dumb pipe then everything else is already lost. Mesh networks only work if you pay the big money for rental on building roofs and existing towers. This money, and so height, and so line of sight, is why cell networks work. You might get some non-profit going in areas especially conducive to it (ie, high population density cities where residents have access to their roofs, or coastal areas with large mountains).
- erikb 8y ago> truly distributed means of hosting is everyone hosting their own websites That means "self-hosted". Distributed hosting means you can't host it in one place. I agree though, that one might consider it as a form of decentralized hosting if everybody hosts their own stuff, which you also totally can now that we have cheap computing power like raspis.
- buboard 8y agothe cheapest computer we all have are home routers. would be nice to them coming with ipfs preinstalled (and perhaps turned on by default!)
- erikb 8y agoThere are some open source router OS projects. I bet they could be convinced to consider such a suggestion with some pull requests, emails and/or a few sponsoring $$$.
- metamet 8y agoComcast charges $10 for every 50 GB of bandwidth used after 1,024 GB a month. Which may be prohibitive. And, unfortunately, some of us don't have a choice of ISP at home.
- erikb 8y agoYeah that's unfortunate. Luckily on HN are also many people who live in more developed countries. ;-) And on a more serious note: Even in your situation a self-hosted solution might be more free. Then don't host it at home, but discuss with universities, hacker/maker clubs and companies in your surroundings and host it behind their internet connection. Usually you need one member of such an organisation to support you and then you can simply do it.
- Noc2 8y agoYou can also use the tool to host things locally. You just need to start an writable ipfs gateway first, see https://blog.florence.chat/tutorial-how-to-host-your-own-file-transfer-service-on-your-pc-22698c9d6362 https://blog.florence.chat/tutorial-how-to-host-your-own-fil...
- Sohcahtoa82 8y ago> Home connections are plenty fast these days. No, they're not. Sure, if you live somewhere where you can get 1 gigabit fiber, maybe. But I know Comcast/Xfinity throttles the crap out of your upload. Even if you get their 1 gigabit plan, your upload is limited to 35 mbps [0]. To put that into perspective, if you have a 1 megabyte image that ends up getting linked on reddit and 100,000 people try to download it in an hour, then you'd need over 200 Mbps upload. Very very few home users have that kind of connection. [0] https://www.cabletv.com/xfinity/internet https://www.cabletv.com/xfinity/internet
- dboreham 8y agoThis isn't how IPFS works FWIW. Your upstream connection is only needed to feed the small number of fetches that aren't cached somewhere else in the network. Much the same as a traditional CDN in that respect.
- Sohcahtoa82 8y agoAh okay. Thank you for the clarification. It sounds similar to Freenet then, with perhaps less of a stress on anonymity.
- RKearney 8y ago> But I know Comcast/Xfinity throttles the crap out of your upload. Even if you get their 1 gigabit plan, your upload is limited to 35 mbps [0]. Odd that you choose their second highest tier to fit your narrative instead of just jumping to their highest tier with is actually symmetrical 2Gbps up and down fiber.
- montecarl 8y agoAre you talking about the "gigabit pro" plan[1]? That is a $300/mo with a 2 year minimum subscription. That clearly is not a residential plan. You might as well just pay for professional hosting at that point. [1] https://www.cabletv.com/xfinity/internet https://www.cabletv.com/xfinity/internet
- dboreham 8y agoIPFS is "truly decentralized" in the sense I think you mean. The publisher runs the origin node. It's the http gateway that isn't. Except it kind of is in that you can use any IPFS http gateway. Ideally clients would use native IPFS, not http, but turnkey native client support in browsers is not here today.
- mathiasrw 8y agoThe browser Brave is working on implementing native support for IPFS so the gateway is not needed: https://github.com/brave/brave-browser/issues/819 https://github.com/brave/brave-browser/issues/819