3 ms·
No. Blockchain isn't a solution to that. Why? A long answer is here (and many other answers) here: https://medium.com/@kaistinchcombe/decentralized-and-trustles
by dmitriid 8y ago
No. Blockchain isn't a solution to that. Why? A long answer is here (and many other answers) here: https://medium.com/@kaistinchcombe/decentralized-and-trustless-crypto-paradise-is-actually-a-medieval-hellhole-c1ca122efdec https://medium.com/@kaistinchcombe/decentralized-and-trustle... (read part one too).
tl;dr
Blockchain systems do not magically make the data in them accurate or the people entering the data trustworthy, they merely enable you to audit whether it has been tampered with. A person who sprayed pesticides on a mango can still enter onto a blockchain system that the mangoes were organic. A corrupt government can create a blockchain system to count the votes and just allocate an extra million addresses to their cronies. An investment fund whose charter is written in software can still misallocate funds.
...
Before blockchain can even get involved, you need to trust that voter registration is done fairly, that ballots are given only to eligible voters, that the votes are made anonymously rather than bought or intimidated, that the vote displayed by the balloting system is the same as the vote recorded, and that no extra votes are given to the political cronies to cast. Blockchain makes none of these problems easier and many of them harder—but more importantly, solving them in a blockchain context requires a set of awkward workarounds that undermine the core premise. So we know the entries are valid, let’s allow only trusted nonprofits to make entries—and you’re back at the good old “classic” ledger. In fact, if you look at any blockchain solution, inevitably you’ll find an awkward workaround to re-create trusted parties in a trustless world.
- seibelj 8y agoYou can audit a small percentage, verify with the original voter it was accurate, and get a statistically significant result about the accuracy.
- dmitriid 8y agoSo you need a trusted party to perform an audit, a trusted party to verify votes with original voters (so, no secret/anonymous voting, so you need a trusted party to handle personal data, a trusted party to destroy that data after elections so that the winner doesn't abuse that data) etc. So, you mean "solving them in a blockchain context requires a set of awkward workarounds that undermine the core premise... In fact, if you look at any blockchain solution, inevitably you’ll find an awkward workaround to re-create trusted parties in a trustless world." So what problem exactly does blockchain solve for voting that isn't already solved better and more efficiently now?
- seibelj 8y agoIf the blockchain containing the votes is distributed to multiple entities, it cannot be tampered without them knowing. Then you can let those entities selectively audit the contents. And then you can follow up with voters, and have them agree or disagree with the accuracy of the record. Compared to messy paper ballots, and electronic voting which is centralized and easy to tamper with, a blockchain solution is much more reliable, tamper-proof, and accurate.
- dmitriid 8y ago> If the blockchain containing the votes is distributed to multiple entities So now you have to find multiple trusted entities. That you trust to: provide proper audits and handle sensitive personal data > And then you can follow up with voters, Who is this you? Another trusted entity? That you have to trust with: handling personal data, be truthful about following up with voters, protecting voter data. And that voters will give you truthful answers. And that this mysterious you doesn't just select "voters" who will tell anything. > Compared to messy paper ballots, and electronic voting which is centralized and easy to tamper with, a blockchain solution is much more reliable, tamper-proof, and accurate. So far you have shown that blockchain solution is: - messy: voter data is no longer anonymised, you need to find multiple trusted agencies to handle personal data. - entirely centralised: everything is done through centralised agencies: centralised audit, centralised "you" who will follow up with voters etc. - extremely easy to tamper with: these "agencies" and this "you" can easily do whatever the hell they want with audits and follow ups - not tamper-proof: the blockhain itself is tamper proof. However, you propose to add a whole host of tamper-prone processes on top of that. - not accurate: so, distribution of voting rights is not accurate, entry of votes into the blockchain is not accurate, the resulting audit is not accurate, the voter follow up is not accurate, but just because there's blockhain in the middle of all of this, this entire process somehow magically becomes accurate? How so?