4 ms·
At the moment I am studying history at my local university (as a hobby to be honest). I am also an industrial engineer by training, a supply chain manager and c
by hef19898 8y ago
At the moment I am studying history at my local university (as a hobby to be honest). I am also an industrial engineer by training, a supply chain manager and currently a project manager for Integrated Logistics Support. And what I realized is that history is focusing a lot on the social side of things. And yes the military side as well (there is one professor who discouraged students to go after military what-ifs if they don't have the propper background).
What they totally lack is technical, economic and trade / supply side of things. Nobody is really looking into stuff like resource allocation during modern war like WW 1 and WW 2 on the level of military gear developed. Lend-lease is an underrepresented topic imho.
So I am not surprised that you with a technical background and an interest in history can provide insight into the importance bn of blacksmiths a pure historian can't.
And if you look at the area where technology, production and military overlap it really gets tricky. Even current experts are struggling for today's challenges. So I can imagine that in a historical context it is even harder, especially without a strong background in one of the three domains and solid knowledge ib at least one of the others.
I guess what I want to say is, let's go easy on zhe guy and provide some additional ideas. Maybe he's reading this discussion.
- benj111 8y agoI wouldn't say logistics is completely ignored, but yes it is under represented. I'm sure I've come across contemporary lists of what lords would have to supply for a mediaeval campaign, (something like each lord shall supply X archers, each with Y arrows, also Z men at arms) so you could work backwards from there. Sorry if I'm teaching my grandmother the suck eggs.
- hinkley 8y agoAs an observer, history teachers have taught me that Rome, Napoleon and maybe Alexander worried about logistics. I theory the message is that they were superlative in their logistical prowess, but in practice we only see a few examples.
- hef19898 8y agoThere are certainly exceptions. I remember one documentory that looked at the theory that the roman empire's strength was infrastructure. I simply feel it is underrepresented.
- ergothus 8y agoAre there any good sources for the layperson? Coincidentally I was searching for average on-person items in different eras today and found little of any use at all (though the dumbing down of search results may be more to blame than lack of sources existing)
- hef19898 8y agoI would suggest to go for experimental archaeology. These guys are just trying out stuff with the tools and tech frombthe appropriate period. There is currently a castle in France under construction, I think they should have some details on stuff like that.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoA very interesting perspective, thanks. Perhaps a little surprised to learn there's not much investigation into those areas. I imagine my reading choice may reflect my background and pick out some that focus on more military, tactical and technical areas. So a fair criticism too.
- johannes1234321 8y ago> Nobody is really looking into stuff like resource allocation during modern war like WW 1 and WW 2 on the level of military gear developed. From a German perspective there is a lot of discussion on this, especially on WW2. Lot's of debate on forced labor for military production (Spielberg even made a movie about this - Schindler's List), discussions on the role of women (who had to take over men's work in civilian areas to keep infrastructure running), lots of discussions in food supply and lots of debates about development of submarines and the V2 rocket. The impact of war on coal mining as well as factories and supply chain and being target for air strikes.
- hef19898 8y agoThat's true. What I miss is more an analysis of the available resources, how these resources have been applied and what kind of equipment was produced and how. From a purely technical perpective one could argue that German tank development, as one example, was not perfectly geared for mass production under war conditions. Some of the welds on genuine WW2 Panthers were better then some you see on 21st century cars. Why would you do that during WW2? Also the maintenance and repair operations of the warring nations in WW2 deserve a much closer look, the framework to be applied is available now, albeit in the engineering domain and not the historical faculties. And resources cover a lot more than just man power., So I would argue that the Allies in both world wars had more resources and industrial capacities and have been more effcient in applying them to the war effort. Obviously tactics play into that as well, as does operations and strategy. When you have more you can afford to burn precious power on risky or unsuccessful operations, when you don't you have to be more cautious in selcting your war goals. Regarding slave labour. That was one way to offset the manpower used for combat. I won't go too deeply into the moral and social aspects of it here, let's just say that this was among the worst things the Germans did in WW2. Again what would be interessting is an analysis of whether it was worth it or not. See, I would assume that using slave labour would result in a much higher degree of rework for the stuff slaves produced. We are talking about Germans here, there have to be at least some numbers out there regarding this. Again, engineering knowledge can help to make sense of these numbers. And I could go on, which was the main reason why I decided to study history (even if it doesn't look like it will lead to anything right now, who would have thought that you can only miss so many lectures to be allowed to take the exam?).