4 ms·

> Sorry. Thanks, but no need for the phony apology. Typefaces, like other graphic elements, might not be felt to the point of the reader explicitly "recognizi

> Sorry. Thanks, but no need for the phony apology. Typefaces, like other graphic elements, might not be felt to the point of the reader explicitly "recognizing" these contributions. Their impact is real albeit subtle. Designers are aware of that but still work really hard anyway.

lobotryas 8y ago
How can you demonstrate or prove that the impact is “real”?
- misterbwong 8y ago
  I think you're confusing real with measurable.
  - Green_man 8y ago
    Alternatively, how are we supposed to know it's real if it's not measurable?
    - deleted 8y ago
      [deleted]
    - crispyambulance 8y ago
      A designer's work is, in large part, sensory and thus "measurable". It might very well be subjective and difficult to put into words, but even if one is a strict positivist, that's acceptable.
- reaperducer 8y ago
  Add a CSS override to someone's browser that forces web sites to display in Comic Sans.
- simonh 8y ago
  There’s a huge amount of research into this sort of thing funded by advertisers and marketers.
- bunderbunder 8y ago
  Assuming (with a tip of the hat to misterbwong) that you want to demonstrate the impact is real by measuring it, A/B testing would be one of the more popular ways to do it nowadays. The kinds of questions you can ask with it are somewhat limited, so you've got to be worried about the trap of searching where the light is better. But it is so very cheap and easy. If you have more resources and need to ask questions A/B testing doesn't handle well, you can also do it with good old-fashioned surveying. Take (say) a few hundred people sampled as representatively as possible from your target market. Randomly show half of them a version of the design that uses one typeface, and the other half a version that uses another. Ask them to rate how well they liked the design. See if there's a difference. Or ask them to recall things they saw, and see if there's a difference.

lobotryas 8y ago

How can you demonstrate or prove that the impact is “real”?

misterbwong 8y ago
I think you're confusing real with measurable.
- Green_man 8y ago
  Alternatively, how are we supposed to know it's real if it's not measurable?
  - deleted 8y ago
    [deleted]
  - crispyambulance 8y ago
    A designer's work is, in large part, sensory and thus "measurable". It might very well be subjective and difficult to put into words, but even if one is a strict positivist, that's acceptable.
reaperducer 8y ago
Add a CSS override to someone's browser that forces web sites to display in Comic Sans.
simonh 8y ago
There’s a huge amount of research into this sort of thing funded by advertisers and marketers.
bunderbunder 8y ago
Assuming (with a tip of the hat to misterbwong) that you want to demonstrate the impact is real by measuring it, A/B testing would be one of the more popular ways to do it nowadays. The kinds of questions you can ask with it are somewhat limited, so you've got to be worried about the trap of searching where the light is better. But it is so very cheap and easy. If you have more resources and need to ask questions A/B testing doesn't handle well, you can also do it with good old-fashioned surveying. Take (say) a few hundred people sampled as representatively as possible from your target market. Randomly show half of them a version of the design that uses one typeface, and the other half a version that uses another. Ask them to rate how well they liked the design. See if there's a difference. Or ask them to recall things they saw, and see if there's a difference.