3 ms·
A lot of the work the article talks about seems to involve manually recording features like the materials and colors used, the position and type of knots and so
by yorwba 8y ago
A lot of the work the article talks about seems to involve manually recording features like the materials and colors used, the position and type of knots and so on, followed by searching for similar patterns in other khipus. Machine learning could conceivably speed up that encoding work.
Given a large enough collection of transcriptions, one could use "sophisticated" techniques like counting ngrams to try and identify common Quechua words. Depending on the content of a single khipu, i.e. whether it's more like a sentence or a longer text, and how similar modern Quechua languages are, it might even be possible to leverage that into a somewhat usable (i.e. sometimes correct) machine translation system.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoSo you'll model the features. Then what? Counting n-grams will tell you nothing useful, unless the language is Quecuha, and a dialect that is well known, at that. But if it is such a dialect, why are we not any closer to understanding it? You don't need machine learning for that, or even a computer; it helps, but the work can be done by hand (see The Golden Bug: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Gold-Bug https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Gold-Bug). For khipu that are clearly not narrative, i.e. include mostly numerical, plus some other, possibly literary information, it would be even harder to pull off. You'd have to understand words out of context, including names etc. At best you might end up modelling the structure of an unintelligible language- like I think was done for the Voynich manuscript. You'd still not be any closer to undestanding it.