11 ms·
I've been hearing repeatedly that the party is building up a "human shield" in case the West will start going after party members individually. There are no be
by baybal2 8y ago
I've been hearing repeatedly that the party is building up a "human shield" in case the West will start going after party members individually.
There are no benefits for an average person in China to join the party aside from your member card doubling as a free public transit ticket.
First, you can't meaningfully participate in the political process in any capacity, without already "being somebody" in the party.
Second, only 1 in 1000 of party members will ever see any chance to work in any meaningful position. Yes, the actual amount of people who do politics in China is no more than ~70-80 thousand extremely privileged people, picked among the most fanatical candidates.
Third, even if you already "is somebody," and passed the impossible odds, and be picked out from the most fanatical party members, your remit will be no more than to blindly execute edicts passed from above.
Fourth, if you survived for over 2 decades in a position of low ranked official, your brains will not. Anybody who spent so much time mentally tortured by routine work and doing meaningless, brain dead "ideological research" will have their spark extinguished, no matter how talented they were.
Fifth, when you turn a grey haired party veteran who can recite all Marx works from memory, and have a genuine chance getting to provincial or national level, you are a useless husk of a person, who can't do anything but mechanically follow the politburo.
Sixth, if you survived even that, and surpassed everybody else at doing that ritual, you end up becoming a man in ranks of Xi Jinpings.
Jiang Zemin, was the only man ever known to "hack" that system, and he is universally hated by party for that.
- shabda 8y agoChina has done remarkably well in last 6 years, lifting half a billion people out of crippling poverty. If their political system is as incompetent as you describe, I wonder how they manage to do so well.
- baybal2 8y agoThat's the mystery for me too. I myself met, I think, close to 100 officials in course of working in electronics industry for 11 years, and not a single one of them strayed from the stereotype I stated above. But even with gross incompetency of individual constituents, that party as a whole, in some absurd and bizarre way, ends up settling on more or less rational policies most of the time.
- samspenc 8y agoI believe that's due to the entrepreneurship and hard work of the individuals in the country, and not of the political system itself. Congratulating the CCP for lifting the country out of poverty would be like thanking the US political parties for making the USA the largest economy in the world (as opposed to the hard-working entrepreneurs and workers who built this country into what it is today.)
- wyuenho 8y agoThe Nazi party also did quite well for a period of time, also the Soviets. Also, no the CCP didn't lift half a billion people out of crippling poverty, the WTO did. The economy in China are markedly different before and after joining the WTO. America gave them a hand, hoping the market would change the system, they hoped wrong.