7 ms·
I just built a home. One thing I noticed: Some builders are really stupid about reading the market and knowing what people are willing to pay. They load homes u
by gwbas1c 8y ago
I just built a home. One thing I noticed: Some builders are really stupid about reading the market and knowing what people are willing to pay. They load homes up with luxury features and then wonder why their homes sit vacant.
My builder has a vacant home in my neighborhood. He ran Ethernet to all rooms, and put in other silly features, and just couldn't comprehend why his price was too high.
- errantmind 8y agoI don't know the details of this home you refer to, but I'd pay more for a home with ethernet in all rooms
- bhauer 8y agoSo would I, since wired networking is my jam. But I get the point the GP is making. The pool of potential buyers who would appreciate the value of that additional investment is small and (presumably) only getting smaller with time. Anecdote: I realized how out of the mainstream I was when recently viewing a video produced by a high-profile gamer on Youtube showing off the specifications of his desktop gaming rig via Windows Task Manager. Yes, he had gobs of memory, many cores, and dual RTXs. But what caught my eye was that the network chart showed he was using wireless networking. On a desktop PC with two RTX 2080s. It make me laugh a bit; it made me cry a bit.
- com2kid 8y agoModern 5ghz wireless can fully saturate most home broadband connections, and if a good router is used, the added latency is trivial. If the house isn't already wired for CAT5, wireless makes sense.
- bhauer 8y agoTo reiterate: the point of my anecdote was to point out how out of touch I am. Sure, wireless gaming is fine. Still, for me, I can't fathom investing the kind of money this fellow had on a gaming rig to then pair it with wireless networking. The scenario in brief: On one hand, I've opted for a blistering no-compromises frame rate, but on the other, I am tolerating a few more milliseconds of lag. Does not compute. I remember enjoying the analysis that Riot did comparing wireless and wired gaming [1]. The chart showing the percentage of players using wired versus wireless at each of their ranking tiers is especially interesting. In my home, I use Ubiquiti UniFi wireless access points. Comparing my workstation (wired) with my laptop (wireless, situated about 10 feet from an access point), pings to Google are delayed ~1.5ms by wireless with a few more random hiccups. Is that a big deal? No, not really for me. But then, I don't really game nor do I have dual RTX 2080s. [1] https://na.leagueoflegends.com/en/page/ethernet-vs-wifi-ping-packets-playing-better https://na.leagueoflegends.com/en/page/ethernet-vs-wifi-ping...
- com2kid 8y agoThanks for the great link! That is an awesome post, those lag spikes are horrible.
- ip26 8y agoIt's fine on bandwidth, but I learned for whatever reason it sucks for network filesystems... 15mbps powerline links absolutely kicked the pants off N900 for SMB performance.
- clairity 8y agowhile we colloquially say CAT5, any new wiring should be CAT6 (or 6A) nowadays since the cost difference is negligible for much more bandwidth.
- walrus01 8y agoEthernet to all rooms is really cheap, like one box of cat5e ($85), some $3 faceplates and $1.50 keystone jacks from monoprice. Assuming he did the typical builder thing of putting a steel box in the wall between two studs somewhere. Plus cost of low voltage installer labor to staple it to wood before the drywall is done, and maybe a $20 patch panel in the in-wall box. And a $9 punchdown tool. I've seen this done by installers who are actually illiterate and everything still passed 1000baseT qualification tests just fine.
- DubiousPusher 8y agoMost construction materials are cheap. Especially at contractor rates. Labor is the expensive part. If you're a contractor you've got to have an hourly rate that covers your business expenses and pays you well. If it takes even just 20 hours of work to run all the Ethernet that's probably about $1500 added to the top line. Added a dozen features like that to a home and you're at $15,000-$20,000 higher asking price to make it worth your while.
- telotortium 8y ago20 hours for just Ethernet? That doesn't pass the sniff test. It seems like something that would be done concurrently with wiring the house, certainly with wiring coax. Even wiring an entire house should take a few hours at most when drywall isn't installed yet.
- DubiousPusher 8y agoNot sure. I've never done it but two long days doesn't seem that crazy to me. Even without drywall up, you're up on a ladder for parts, you gotta hang boxes, you gotta bore a bunch of holes, you gotta do the punching. It adds up. Between planning, routing, testing and the time it adds to drywalling I think it could be more. But again, I've never done it so I don't know for sure. I've just strung a fair amount of Romex which takes longer than you'd expect.
- CivBase 8y ago> He ran Ethernet to all rooms, and put in other silly features Isn't this normal by now? My house is only a few years old but wasn't particularly expensive. When I bought it, it was already wired up with ethernet - I just had to replace the wall plates (they were RJ11 outlets instead of RJ45) and hook up an ethernet switch. From what I've seen of other homes, it appears to be common for electricians to use ethernet for phone lines. Why wouldn't you? The difference in material costs is neglegable. Why should this significantly increase the cost of a new home? Re-wiring an old home is annoying, but I don't see any reason why it should cost much for a new home.
- ams6110 8y agoBecause 90% of non-tech people don't like wires. Nobody runs ethernet cables to all their devices. They don't want to have to worry about an Ethernet switch in the basement or a closet. Having a Wi-Fi router/cable modem in the bedroom is the most they want to worry about. With wireless networking they can have their devices wherever they want, without extra wires.
- thrower123 8y agoThe number of people that don't even have a real Wifi router and just use the POS combination modem/router that Comcast provides (and charges a frankly usurious rental fee for) them bears this out.
- joking 8y agoIn my country new built houses must have both Ethernet cat5 and coaxial TV cable run to every room. The wall plate can be rj11 however. The cost at build time is negligible.
- gizmo686 8y agoHow expensive is Ethernet to all rooms? That decision strikes me as a no brainer for any newly built house. Even if no one actually wants Ethernet in all rooms, it guarantees that Ethernet is present in the particular room(s) that the eventual buyer will want it in. And it will still be present in the particular room(s) that the next buyer will want it in. In contrast, if a room is missing Ethernet, it would be far more expensive to add it in after the fact.
- ams6110 8y agoIn 5 years, Ethernet outlets in homes will be like telephone outlets are today: a relic of a prior generation. I don't know anyone under age 50 who still has a landline phone. The next generation of home buyers won't know what an Ethernet cable is. Everything will be wireless. Apple doesn't even have Ethernet ports on their laptops anymore.
- gizmo686 8y agoWired connections are still needed for some professionals, and as we shift to more remote work (think remotely operating robots), the need for reliable network connections will increase. Perhaps more importantly, wireless still connects to a wired router which needs to be somewhere in the house (unless we switch to more long-distance wireless, which I don't see happening anytime soon without both technical and political advances). In my house, a major upgrade we did was install 3 additional access points, and we still have dead zones in one area because there was no Ethernet port (it would be 2, but one was a bedroom, so we ran a wire along the wall. Ugly, but bedrooms need wifi). You are certainly correct that most people won't need Ethernet ports in every room
- nitwit005 8y agoYou need to plug your wifi in somewhere, which means it needs a cable. Many people have multiple wifi devices, which means multiple cables. And while wifi is pretty good now, people still hit issues and plug in their various TV devices and game consoles.
- closeparen 8y ago
- yardie 8y ago> Ethernet to all rooms, and put in other silly features I feel wired ethernet is essential. 2.4GHz is saturated and 5.8GHz has trouble penetrating certain rooms. I'm lucky that my 10yo condo has Cat5 wiring to telephone jacks in each room. Rather than an expensive wire run I just punch in new jacks. What boggles my mind is poorly designed designer kitchens, bathrooms, and closets. Like adding granite countertops and a built in espresso maker suddenly means luxury. Our old apartment has less square footage yet felt 2x as large.