6 ms·
Bitcoin plunges again. Now the only currency worse than Bitcoin is Venezuela’s
- dragontamer 8y agoBCH-ABC vs BCH-SV was a online flame war that only really involved the 4th largest coin (BCH). But why would it be the cause of this latest downward slide? There's a theory that the BCH-ABC vs BCH-SV war brought to light: that "trustless" doesn't really mean trustless. It means "trustless, as long as you trust the coin". Innately, the BCH-ABC vs BCH-SV flamewar destroyed the notion of trustless and decentralized. Anyway, I don't really know why BTC has done so poorly here. And the correlation to the BCH-ABC vs BCH-SV war may have just been coincidence. But its worth thinking about and discussing... maybe we can learn something from the past few weeks. -------- Alternatively: "Store of Value" was a self-defeating prophesy. BTC was a "good" store of value, until it lost 50%+ in just a week or two. So as BTC fell, it just fell harder and harder, as the "store of value" argument was defeated.
- garmaine 8y ago> trustless, as long as you trust the coin What is your intended meaning here?
- dragontamer 8y agoMy main point is that the word "Trustless" has been abused repeatedly over the past year. "Bitcoin Trustless" doesn't mean what most people think it meant. And it was most obvious when people were forced to pick sides in the BCH-ABC vs BCH-SV flamewars.
- yebyen 8y agoI have picked a side, and I won't tell you which one, but I'm not sure that I've been forced to monetarily pick a side. In fact I've seen enough propaganda around "unified" coin that sounds a lot like "you better not have picked a side yet," I still think there might be some advantage to have not picked a side, and to maintain that. Are most exchanges picking a side yet? (What side are you on?)
- yebyen 8y agoI will never understand what motivates some people to downvote rather than reply (unless you tell me...)
- bb88 8y agoYou're trusting the developers and the code that the developers write.
- garmaine 8y agoIn principle, no. You're supposed to review the code you run. The open-source status of bitcoin is a vital part of its security model. This isn't a nitpicky point either. Bitcoin has specifically avoided any sort of automatic update mechanism, and not just because of the security risks involved. Additionally many companies and miners take their time evaluating new releases before upgrading.
- bb88 8y ago> You're supposed to review the code you run. Really? After spending years watching the pro-bitcoin people shill their crap, this is the first argument I've seen espousing a requirement to understand the code before using your wallet.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- wpietri 8y agoThe pretty obvious explanation as to why it is doing poorly is that it was a bubble. People bought it because it was going up, which caused it to go up further. Now that it's going down, nobody wants to buy it and a lot of people want to sell it. As far as I can see, there's no particular reason to expect the slide to end here. Stocks have a valuation floor based on income and assets. Commodities have floors based on the people who use those commodities to create economic value. Most currencies have a floor for many reasons, but partly because a central bank will stand behind it and defend its price. Bitcoin has none of those.
- bb88 8y ago> As far as I can see, there's no particular reason to expect the slide to end here. The real bottom is underpinned by the "True Blue Bitcoin Believers", who will most likely die than sell their bitcoin shares. In a few years we'll realize the true value of Bitcoin wasn't the blockchain, but it's existence as a curiosity of sorts, where people were buying and selling purely imaginary things -- numbers -- which had no real value in the real world.
- wpietri 8y agoYes indeed. Although I'm not sure the TBBBs will provide much of a floor. Holding doesn't prop up the price; they have to keep buying. I heard somebody refer to Bitcoins as "math beanie babies", which certainly fits your model.
- gammateam 8y agoThe reason it would be part of a catalyst for the latest downward slide is because Craig Wright masquarades as Satoshi Nakamoto, who owns 10% of all Bitcoin. Although Craig Wright has never proved his ownership, he is wealthy by any stretch, and threatened to sell his bitcoin into the market. The people and funds holding support levels around $6,000 USD pulled their bid in the face of this, and helped panic sell. Craig Wright has not moved any of Satoshi Nakamoto's mined coins. Secondly, Roger Ver exists on the other side of the war. He owns a large cloud mining farm, and has been redirecting hash rate that customers paid for. He has been redirecting it away from Bitcoin to his Bitcoin ABC fork, to help win this ego war. He is paying the customers in his bitcoin still, so that they don't have a disruption in payouts. Ultimately, there is a lot more bitcoin on the market to fund the bitcoin-cash war, between two very wealthy people. This has nothing to do with your theory of trust. There's just more supply than demand. Anybody can hedge their store of value. You can hedge the USD value changes with futures, you can hedge gold, you can hedge bitcoin, any currency or commodity really. Your conclusions are misguided, but there is room for market maturity in bitcoin.
- nostrademons 8y agoThe logic behind the BCH-ABC/SV war affecting BTC prices was that both of the principals behind the BCH split were early Bitcoin investors with substantial BTC holdings, and they were selling off these holdings to prop up the value of their preferred currencies and fund mining equipment. There's some evidence for that in both their Twitter statements and the fact that BCH-SV has skyrocketed as every other cryptocurrency plummets, but ultimately I find it a little unconvincing. BAB (BCH-ABC) has also dropped recently, and I doubt that even a rich egomaniac can affect the whole BTC market as much as has happened recently. I'd chalk it more to capitulation as the previous bubble bursts.
- garmaine 8y agoThat’s really cherry picking dates. Use 12 months instead of Dec 31st and it’s only down 50%, not 80%. Use 18 months and it’s actually in the green. Bitcoin is volatile. No one disputes that.
- wpietri 8y agoAnybody who ever called it a store of value was disputing that.
- garmaine 8y agoIf you zoom out the graph it has been a pretty good store of value. It just has many boom-bust cycles overlaid on top. Would you say equities or housing are a poor store of value, comparing early 2007 to late 2008?
- taurath 8y agoEquities and housing have some floor from the value of scrap materials - the value floor for a failed idea is 0.
- garmaine 8y agoThe value floor of a trust minimized machine arbitration system is not zero. It is the aggregate cost of displaced legal and financial services, which can be substantial.
- bb88 8y agoYes, yes it is 0. Why I don't have to use your trust minimized machine arbitration system, when I can build my own, just like the 1,000 or so other alt-coins.
- garmaine 8y agoWhich would also be included in that valuation, the total value of which would be equal to or greater than the alternative costs.
- KasianFranks 8y agoThis is when you buy.
- wpietri 8y agoBy that theory, you should be putting your money in the Venezuelan Bolivar. If a big fall means a big buying opportunity, then the Bolivar's the clear winner, as it has fallen farther.
- gammateam 8y agoeh I'll take the -8 downvotes. Programmers aren't dip buyers, only early adopters, but not great traders. You won't get much consensus on this reality.
- yebyen 8y agoReal talk, you have to plan your bitcoin hodling around tax season, with the worst possible outcomes always in mind. Wait until next March, when US taxes are due, or until next May after the timely returns have been paid off already... "The market can remain irrational for longer than you will remain solvent." I certainly am not one who has made out, inasmuch, like a bandit as many Bitcoin investors may have, but I've been following Bitcoin for a long time (as long as it's been around) and the best, most outlasting advice, true in most markets and not unique or special at all in any way is still "don't put all your eggs in one basket." If taxes come to be accepted in Bitcoin across the nation, this might turn out to be a game-changer. Or it might mean nothing. I don't know what the state taxes are like in Ohio[1], but this is an interesting development to be sure. Regardless, you should continue to plan around the uncertainty that comes on either side of "tax season." Bitcoin or not. [1]: https://techcrunch.com/2018/11/25/ohio-becomes-the-first-state-to-accept-bitcoin-for-tax-payments/ https://techcrunch.com/2018/11/25/ohio-becomes-the-first-sta...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Wait until next March, when US taxes are due April 15 is usually not in March.
- Ologn 8y agoMarch 15 is when US S-corp and partnership taxes are due. April 15 is when US individual income taxes are due. When to pay (for some people, both days) depends on how a person has their finances set up.
- yebyen 8y agoI was basically assuming you're ahead of the game, since your paperwork must be in at March to be on-time, unless you file for yourself or if your accountant really likes you, I guess... you're right, the deadline is in April, and I assume similarly, charitably, that taxes paid in May as I said are mostly on-time, while that's not strictly true. YMMV IANAL this is not legal advice, if your tax budget is not already ready to be paid off in March, then I wish good luck to you.
- taurath 8y ago> The reason bitcoin miners are willing to do the very real work of processing transactions is that they think the bitcoin they're getting paid with will keep rising in value. And what would make them do that? Well, the finite supply certainly helps, but at some point there has to be more demand for them too. Which means that people have to actually start using them. I can't help but feel some similarities to housing bubbles here.
- bb88 8y agoAnd demand will only return when the price stabilizes. And because the price isn't stabilizing, demand isn't coming back.
- Spartan-S63 8y agoNot to mention that Bitcoin has a very low value proposition outside of being a store of value. I can see a crypto economy where Bitcoin backs the value of other cryptocurrencies, but it’s not a good first-party currency. It’s a mere store of values nd people don’t really agree that it’s useful to exchange for services. They just see it as useful to hold value. Something like Ethereum, with a real value-proposition, is a more worthwhile cryptocurrency. Basically, I see crypto evolving into pseudo-fiat currencies with some large financial institution (that isn’t a nation-state) ensuring it’s a valuable commodity. I’m just not convinced we can (or should) escape a fiat-like economic system.
- bb88 8y agoI would argue it's not even a store of value anymore with the price tumbling. When you buy bitcoin or ethereum, you get what? A number. I can sell you a number. Better yet, I can sell you a cryptographically signed number if you want. But that itself is just a number. At some point, even something like gold has a certain amount of scarcity. But with crypto, there's no scarcity, even if you can artificially limit the number of coins. One can always just create a new bitcoin alternative... The point is, there is nothing, absolutely nothing, that underpins the price of a BTC to anything in the real world.
- RaceWon 8y agoAm I wrong in believing that if not for Silk Road, BTC would have never gotten above $10 at Most?
- panarky 8y agoThe only currency worse than Bitcoin is Venezuela's over the last 12 months Every national currency is far, far worse than Bitcoin over the last 24 months, 36 months, 48 months, 60 months, 72 months, and so on back to its inception
- lupinglade 8y agoWho could have seen this coming? Heh