3 ms·
I'm not keen on the total karma display. I take your point that it's useful as a vague reply indicator, but it would be more useful still if there was an actual
by jdietrich 16y ago
I'm not keen on the total karma display. I take your point that it's useful as a vague reply indicator, but it would be more useful still if there was an actual indicator of new replies, in the style of Reddit's red envelope. I don't know whether such a thing would be feasible for HN.
I would like to see total karma disappear altogether, because I don't think it measures anything helpful and may well be counterproductive. Looking down the HN karma leaderboard[1] you can see a number of users with very high total karma but very low average karma. I'm sure that some of these users make a valuable contribution, but some seem to post a vast number of very low-value comments that are rarely replied to and receive only occasional upvotes. I'm not sure that we want to encourage that style of participation.
[1] http://news.ycombinator.com/leaders http://news.ycombinator.com/leaders
- iuguy 16y agoI quite like the total karma display. It gives me something to aim for. In the past few weeks I've made an effort to post in threads rather than my usual lurking and I'm using my overall score as a crude means of whether or not I should be posting more. I'm trying to go up by about 100 a week, which focuses me more on commenting early in the life of a thread and engaging in conversation instead of posting at the end of a thread's life or adding me too posts. I would definitely love an equivalent of the reddit envelope, along with a view of replies.
- jamesteow 16y ago"You can see a number of users with very high total karma but very low average karma. I'm sure that some of these users make a valuable contribution, but some seem to post a vast number of very low-value comments that are rarely replied to and receive only occasional upvotes." I comment in a lot of new stories/links that pop up, especially people asking critiques because a) it's disheartening to post something about your work and have zero replies and b) I often get to see a cool product that's in a very raw stage and hear feedback from the creator themselves. In fact, I'd say less than 25% of my comments are in front page links. But often these new stories rarely get traffic. And my comments will usually just get one or no upvotes at all from the creator, despite their thanks for the criticism. Just saying that not all low-averaged scores are people not actively trying to make a contribution.