3 ms·
> The cynic in me feels like we're writing giant book-length stories that are just cover to get people to reduce their sugar intake. I feel that's factual, not
by ars 8y ago
> The cynic in me feels like we're writing giant book-length stories that are just cover to get people to reduce their sugar intake.
I feel that's factual, not cynical. That's exactly what all the different weird diets that people love to make fun of do: Convince people in all sorts of ways to eat less.
All the rules and whatever of the diet have just the one goal.
We should stop evaluating diet plans based on weight loss (since they are all basically the same), and instead evaluate them based on compliance.
- tonystubblebine 8y ago> instead evaluate them based on compliance. Or rather, evaluate people for which diet they're most likely to comply with. One of the flaws in the personal development ecosystem is that because everyone is selling their own "one weird trick" there's no incentive to build good assessment programs. It's not diet, but probably the only top author with a solid assessment is Gretchen Rubin and her habit tendencies. All the tendencies lead back to her advice, but at least they acknowledge that not all people are the same.
- pfranz 8y agoI've always suggested people find one that works for them. My father in law loves competition and numbers, so Weight Watchers lets him accumulate points. My wife hates cheat days and they don't really have the intended effect on her. She's also fine eating the same thing almost every day. A lot of the fad diets are fairly similar in that they're low-carb and reduce sugar; Atkins, South Beach, Keto, Whole30.