3 ms·
Maybe the right answer here is to cook (or otherwise sterilize) our food before we eat it, or else accept that not doing so is risky? The prevalence of contagi
by yellowapple 8y ago
Maybe the right answer here is to cook (or otherwise sterilize) our food before we eat it, or else accept that not doing so is risky? The prevalence of contagions in uncooked/undercooked meat is already well-known; uncooked/undercooked lettuce apparently warrants similar treatment.
Sure, if it's easy and cheap to test and sterilize irrigation water, then let's do so. I strongly doubt that's the case, though, and requiring farms to do so is one of those regulations that would be a small dent in a large corporate farm's checkbook and a gaping hole in that of a small independent farm.
- rtkwe 8y agoYou can't really cook greens to sterilize them they'll just wilt and won't be the same food even.
- sp332 8y agoRestaurants have had similar problems with sprouts (like mung bean sprouts) and their solution largely has been to stop serving them. Except Jimmy Johns, which makes users click a button that confirms it's a health risk. https://arstechnica.com/science/2018/01/raw-sprouts-at-jimmy-johns-linked-to-another-outbreak-at-least-the-7th/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2018/01/raw-sprouts-at-jimmy...
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoI've eaten bean sprouts cooked on the street in dubious conditions in various Asian countries and never contracted anything as a result. The risk to health must be vanishingly small.
- sp332 8y agoThis is about raw bean sprouts.
- yellowapple 8y agoYou can say the same thing about meat (especially fish). I love me some good nigiri or sashimi. I also know full well that by eating nigiri or sashimi instead of, say, a cooked filet, I'm increasing my risk of contracting food-borne illnesses.
- rosser 8y ago> Sure, if it's easy and cheap to test and sterilize irrigation water, then let's do so. The figures I've repeatedly seen say that ~$10-15mm worth of testing would have saved > $100mm worth of medical and related expenses — so far. An order of magnitude cost savings is, by most definitions I'm aware of, a serious bargain. What? The farmers aren't paying everyone else's medical bills? "Externalized costs are, like, totally someone else's problem, man..."
- yellowapple 8y agoThe farmers (at least the ones growing lettuce) aren't the ones who are externalizing their costs, though. By imposing the expenses of testing and sterilization on them, they're bearing the costs that other farmers further upstream (literally) are externalizing by allowing their livestock to contaminate the water. If we're to try to fix this with regulation, that's where we need to start. Making lettuce farmers bear the brunt of this is like issuing a traffic ticket to a driver because he got pushed through a red light by someone else. Meanwhile, testing is only half the battle. Let's say the water is contaminated. Unless you're okay with not having water (and therefore not having crops), you'd need to sterilize that water somehow. You'd need a machine that can boil and re-cool the water; just boiling it isn't enough unless you want to pre-cook your crops before the leave the farm ;) (but you could certainly let it cool in a reservoir before sending it to crops). Or maybe you have some fancier machine that uses something like radiation to do the sterilization. Either way, that costs money. Big corporate farms can easily afford that. Small independent farms typically cannot. The idea that regulation like this can completely kill small-scale agricultural practices ain't far-fetched; this has quite literally happened again and again. I'm personally/intimately familiar with the case of Loyalton, CA, which used to have a thriving dairy (particularly milk and cheese) industry up until the middle of the 20th Century, when new pasteurization requirements made continued operation too expensive for all these small-scale dairies. As a result, they all switched to beef and alfalfa, and now that's all you see. So if we are going to go ahead and make testing and sterilization mandatory, then we'll definitely want to subsidize it (whether for all farms or just for ones below a certain size). Given that it'll save the country money in the long run, as you say, this should be easy to justify budget-wise.